More turbine mayhem, this time it’s Siemens turbines – less than 4 years old – collapsing on Maui – an island in the Hawaiian archipelago.
Parts fall off wind turbine
The Maui News
4 October 2016
The blades, hub and nacelle of one of eight Auwahi Wind turbines in the Kanaio area separated from the tower and fell to the ground Sunday, an official with the wind-power generation company said Monday.
There were no injuries, and the damage was limited to the one turbine, said Jill Howard, manager of communications and marketing for San Diego-based Sempra U.S. Gas & Power, the owner of the wind farm.
“We are in the very early stages of investigating the situation and gathering facts,” Howard said in an email Monday night. “This includes working closely with Siemens, the turbine manufacturer, to determine the root cause and corrective actions.”
As a precaution, all of the turbines at the 21-megawatt wind farm have been shut down until the investigation is completed, Howard said.
Shayna Decker, spokeswoman for Maui Electric Co., which receives wind power from Auwahi, confirmed Monday afternoon that the utility was not receiving power from the wind farm.
“It is too soon to know how long this comprehensive investigation will take,” said Howard.
According to the final Environmental Impact Statement for the project, filed in August 2011, each tower weighs a total of 283 tons, based on transport weight. The nacelle, which houses all of the generating components of a wind turbine, is 82.5 tons, alone.
Each tower is 262 feet high with blades running 166 feet, according to the EIS.
The report said that each unit is equipped with a controller that allows the wind tower generator to operate when wind speeds are between 8 and 55 mph. High wind speeds can damage the units.
The report said that “it is very rare” for a wind tower generator “to collapse or a rotor blade to be dropped or thrown from the nacelle, but such incidents do occur and are potentially dangerous for site personnel and the general public.”
A tower collapse or blade throw can result from “improper design, manufacturing or installation; wind gusts exceeding the . . . maximum design load; or from lightning strikes,” according to the report.
Compliance with industry design, construction and operational standards “appropriately and effectively reduce the potential for tower collapse and blade throw,” the report said.
The wind farm, with a footprint of about 68 acres on Ulupalakua Ranch land, has an estimated 20-year lifespan. The power purchase agreement with MECO, approved by the Public Utilities Commission in June 2011, was for 20 years.
The 21-MW wind farm went online in December 2012.
The line about wind turbines having “an estimated 20-year lifespan” is utter bunkum: these things have an economic lifespan of around 11 years (see our post here); and Siemens turbines in the Californian desert, at Ocotillo began falling apart in less than 2 years (see our post here).
The pitch in the report from the operator that “it is very rare” for a wind tower generator “to collapse or a rotor blade to be dropped or thrown from the nacelle” is a delicious gift to STT.
We’ll share our delight at smashing that one for 6 with this lengthy pictorial – starting with a few tower collapses:
With gravity one of nature’s constants, wind farm neighbours can hardly rest assured. Expect more of the same.
Then there is the ‘minor’ issue of ‘component liberation’.
Turbine blade failures, including events where 10 tonne blades are thrown to the 4 winds are so common that we have considered running a separate site dedicated to their aerial escapades – here’s a few to whet your appetite for destruction (the captions are linked to the stories behind the pictures):
Now that those who are forced to travel past, live with and work near these things know how rare it is for 10 tonne blades to be thrown to the 4 winds; how rare it is for 60 tonne rotors to drop 90m from the heavens; and how rare it is for 160m high, 290 tonne turbines to plummet to Earth, we expect you feel a whole lot safer. No?
Welcome to your wind powered future.