Wind Turbine Noise Deprives Farmers and Truckers of Essential Sleep & Creates Unnecessary Danger for All

sleep with turbines


Deprive someone of a decent night’s sleep and the wheels start to fall off pretty quickly.

In the absence of quality sleep, it’s not long and people start suffering mood swings, impaired mental function, lose capacity for abstract thought and – if operating heavy machinery or driving – become a danger to workmates and/or fellow road users.

Next time some tobacco advertising guru or other apologist for the harm caused by giant fans starts mouthing off that there are no adverse health effects from turbine noise, flick them a copy of the WHO Night-time Noise Guidelines for Europe – the Executive Summary at XI to XII covers the point – and a copy of Anne Schafer’s brilliant survey of AGL’s victims at Macarthur.

STT thinks they’ll be reduced to arguing the unarguable.  The only response left is, of course, to attack the victims.  Ah, but that takes very special kind of person.

Sleep is essential for good health.  THE most prevalent adverse health impact from giant industrial wind turbines is noise related sleep deprivation.

We’ve covered the fact that Industrial Noise – is always and everywhere a public health issue and that Sleep Deprivation the Most Common Adverse Health Effect Caused by Wind Turbine Noise.

Depriving anyone of a decent night’s sleep is tantamount to cruel and unusual punishment; to inflict that punishment on people trying to sleep in their own homes is an invasion of their property rights; and, therefore, amounts to a form of theft, as well:

Wind Turbine Infrasound: an “Acoustic Trespasser” 

But stealing someone’s ability to get a solid 8 in the sack, has particular consequences for those who work with dangerous tools, machinery; or those who jump behind the wheel of a 60 tonne B-Double, and thunder off on days long treks, on Australia’s endless highways.

tired driver

Not just a deadly risk to himself ….


Australian heavy vehicle drivers are all subject to very strict rules about the maximum time behind the wheel, rest intervals and sleep. The assumption is that if the driver is off the road, then he or she will be catching some ZZZs; and, thereafter, be refreshed for yet another 8 hour slog down the road, before taking another scheduled break. All of these common sense rules are aimed at road safety – the driver’s own, and every other road user. And fair enough, too.

post hole digger2

Many a leg has been mangled by these little fellas.


Farmers often jump behind the wheel of trucks in the wee-hours to get stock to markets or grain to silos; and spend endless hours on tractors during cropping activities. And there are a range of other dangerous activities that require a farmer to have their wits about them: operating post-hole diggers; and hanging onto a whirring handpiece while shearing or crutching a thumping big wether keen to avoid losing any part of its fibrous coat, to name a couple.


The ‘blind’ blow up the neck: not a time for wits to be dimmed by fatigue.


So, to deprive this class of people of a decent night’s sleep creates a health and safety problem, with the potential for some very serious impacts.

Ron and Chris Jelbart are farmers who live next door to AGL’s Macarthur wind farm disaster in Western Victoria. Chris has detailed, in graphic terms, her suffering, caused by the incessant low-frequency noise and infrasound generated by 140 3MW Vestas V112s, since they kicked into operation in October 2012, in hundreds of complaints to AGL; and as set out in this letter to the local rag:

From: Chris JelbartSent: Tuesday, September 10, 2013 7:05 PM
Subject: wind farm noise

Dear Sir,

I write in answer both to Nick Thies (Saturday letter), and to AGL (Tuesday Standard article). No-one who has not lived next to a wind farm can speak about the effects.

Multi-disciplinary scientific research has NOT been carried out.  Any evidence is usually produced by groups or individuals who don’t want the truth known.  Any evidence contrary to their views is ignored.

The extensive testing done by AGL by “independent” acoustic companies rely on parameters set by AGL so that full spectrum testing is not done.  Sounds or noise that they don’t want are filtered out.  Their testing could be compared with Collingwood being able to choose their own umpire on Saturday.  I am sure the result would have been to Collingwood’s advantage.

The Senate recommended TWO years ago that research should be done, but nothing has happened.  Now people surrounding the Macarthur Wind Energy Facility are suffering the consequences.

Why should we have to put up with disturbed and broken night’s sleep?  Why should I have to hang over the sink dry-retching as I get lunch organised for the day? (I am 58 and not pregnant.)  Why should my friends and neighbours suffer headaches, palpitations and head pressure?  Why should families have to leave their homes to escape the effects of both audible and inaudible noise?

Not all people suffer from these problems.  Some began experiencing symptoms immediately, for me it took at least 6 months.  Others around the district are becoming more aware of problems as time goes on.  It is NOT Simon Chapman’s nocebo effect. Some of those suffering believed we were talking utter nonsense 12 months ago.

We have to put up with the ridicule of people who live in their cities and towns with no clue of what is happening in our homes, expressing their disbelief at our suffering.

If AGL truly believes that their WEF at Macarthur is compliant, and not causing the distress that the surrounding residents are suffering, then it should encourage totally independent research to refute our suggestion to the contrary.
Chris Jelbart

anti wind car

Ron Jelbart and pointed mobile statement.


Ron, and their son, Peter recently gave evidence to the Senate Inquiry into the great wind power fraud at Portland (see our post here) – evidence of the kind described by Senator Bob Day as “harrowing”:

Australian Senators – Day, Leyonhjelm & Canavan – Line Up to Can Big Wind

Peter also presented this submission.

Peter Jelbart
Penshurst, Victoria

This is my submission in regard to the senate enquiry to wind farms.

My name is Peter Jelbart, I am 31 years old and grew up at our home property, where mum and dad farm to this day. It was a great place to grow up and my upbringing, although it was not perfect, was very good.

I remember as a young child dad working away shearing 5 days a week and farming on weekends, to hold onto the dream of farming grandpa’s block.

I remember them having to sell land up the road, and only just holding onto the home block. I remember as a primary school age kid feeding hay and grain to sheep after school, while dad was away for, at times, weeks.

I remember sheep being pitted and being told to play while the crack of 22 bullets rang out and truck load after truck load of sheep got dumped in a pit. This was in the early 90’s, wool was bad, land was worth nothing and interest rates were running into the 20% region.

However, as bad as things were at home mum and dad did everything they could for us. Obviously education was a priority, as was being involved with local football and cricket. The farm and home means everything to us. It is my parent’s life’s work, superannuation and life savings, all in one neat block of Western Victorian dirt.

From the age of 19 I moved to Port Fairy to play football and fell into work driving trucks, which I have loved from as early as I can remember. I lived in town for 3 years, and then moved to Portland for a year before ending up in Western Australia.

Since I started driving trucks I have been very focused on firstly building a career and secondly trying to work toward financial security. I have been quite successful at this early stage.

As I sit here writing this I am financially secure, happy and healthy. But there is a big problem. I am back at home after working away and the Macarthur Industrial Wind Turbines are driving me mad. I have had disrupted sleeps since day one of operation, but only when I stay at home. I am not neurotic or psychotic, I do not suffer from “The Nocebo Effect”, I have very disrupted sleep at home.

As a truck driver I have become used to sleeping in different environments. I have worked big hours in the past. I have slept beside busy highways often, and in Western Australia I regularly slept with an “Ice Pack” running, which is basically a diesel motor that runs a refrigerated air con unit and an alternator, which is used when the truck is parked, to cool the bunk. Initially these take a lot of getting used to. They are noisy and they cycle. They cut in and out but once I’m asleep they don’t worry me. I have become very aware of the way I sleep since I started to be disrupted by the Macarthur IWF.

My parent’s farm is within a couple of kilometres from the nearest tower, not that that means anything to you or to us, as we may as well have a tower on the back lawn.

From an aesthetic point of view they are unattractive. It is not this that that worries me. The Industrial Wind Turbines are not necessarily noisy, although they are audible most days. The problem is the sleep disruption, the inaudible noise and the “un-feelable” vibration.

We are suffering a very real and serious problem at home. Dad is suffering from severe sleep disruption; I have severely interrupted sleep, mixed with lucid dreams. I have been fortunate to spend most of my time away from home since the Macarthur IWTs started.

I have recently ended up living at home again and this has only reinforced what I already knew, that there is a serious problem coming from the emissions of the IWTs next door.

As a professional heavy vehicle driver I know about fatigue. I have sat through courses related to fatigue management yearly for the last ten years. I have worked big hours, illegal hours, and I know what tired is. I know what sleep is. I know the principals of circadian rhythms, how to handle shift work, what to eat, what to drink and what to avoid.

I also know that the sleep, or lack of, that happens at home, is completely foreign. It is not a problem with my head, my mind, my body, or anything else. It is a problem from being externally stimulated by the IWTs close to home. It is a combination of infrasound and low frequency noise. “Noise” that doesn’t get measured by planners, government, hosts or acousticians. “Noise” that doesn’t exist. “Noise” that is all in our heads. “Noise” that is completely denied by wind farm companies.

For years I have dreamed of running a truck of my own. Ideally I would use home as a base. This is no longer a viable option because of the sleep issue. How can I as a heavy vehicle driver, whose fatigue is measured in 15 minute intervals, with fines starting at $600 for minor breaches, work out of a place where I can’t sleep? What am I to do when I can’t turn up fit for duty, even if I spent 8 hours in bed?

Wind is a dirty industry, built on lies, mistruths and hypotheticals. It is an unsustainable industry. It will cost Australia dearly, not just now but into the future. We at home are merely political road kill. We don’t matter. As the great green con rolls on, our lives have been disrupted to a level unimaginable to almost all. Unless you personally experience the disruption, the sleepless nights, the constant battering, you don’t get it.

I have only touched on the most personal issue to me, the disrupted sleep. There are far more qualified people out there who will hopefully make submissions outlining the political and financial failings of wind farms. I can live in the shadows of a wind farm, I can put up with the industrialisation of the landscape. The thing I can’t handle is not being able to sleep at home.

My submission is to outline purely the fact there is a real and proper concern as far as sleep deprivation and sleep disturbance go as neighbours of a wind farm. I realise there are too many people investing too much money and I realise that politicians and policy makers don’t like knowing or admitting that they have been lied to, conned and bluffed by wind energy, and as such I doubt any real outcome will be achieved by this senate enquiry, although I thank anyone who holds real concern for us.

The only thing that I can realistically relate wind energy to is asbestos, and maybe tobacco. For how long have we heard the proponents claiming all the upsides with no side effects, at all, EVER!!

Wake up to the con, the lies, the bullshit, that is wind, before more disruption to good everyday people takes place. There is a reason a senate enquiry is taking place and it is about time some real answers were heard from people affected by wind farms.

Peter Jelbart
Submission 270
Select Committee on Wind Turbines

truck crash

Fatigue risk realised: another potential wind industry impact.

About stopthesethings

We are a group of citizens concerned about the rapid spread of industrial wind power generation installations across Australia.


  1. Jackie Rovenksy says:

    If anyone believes sleep deprivation is OK, they should stand in the shoes of the emergency service personnel who have to attend road accidents, where people have fallen asleep at the wheel.

    For anyone in the Medical Profession to dismiss the effects of sleep deprivation and other adverse effects of living in the vicinity of these gigantic noise emitters by either writing publicly that these people are only suffering from what is actually a nonsensical theoretical unprovable condition called ‘nocebo’, or by sending them to talk to the company who is causing their agony for advice, then they should be de-registered – because they are not undertaking their duty of care to patients, but replacing it with their personal, ideological views, rather than treating patients symptoms with conscientious care.

    Every medical doctor who subscribes to the idea these turbines are safe and cannot cause health impacts, and believes those reporting adverse health effects should be ignored, should stand up and have their names published, so people can avoid them and find treatment from those who know what their duty of care really is.

    These doctors in their stupidity will be sending patients away who need treatment and understanding. Turning their back on these patients is adding to the trauma these patients are suffering.

    Sleep deprivation alone leads to other illnesses. And sleep deprivation in this instance is not something in isolation from the existence of Massive Invasive Turbines operating in the vicinity of these peoples homes. These people are reporting symptoms consistent with a constant unrelenting physical attack on their bodies.


    • Sommer says:

      I agree with everything you are saying Jackie…except one thing. Patients reporting sleep disturbance from industrial wind turbines too close to their homes do not need treatment. They need to have the turbines turned off and then dismantled.

      • Jackie Rovenksy says:

        I agree, but if symptoms are treated and get no better then the Doctors need to record the symptoms are not getting better and if the case that they are getting worse over time.

        What some of these Doctors are doing/proposing is coming to a diagnosis laden with bias and personal ideology, after steadfastly accepting the AMA’s diatribe which was based on a single line from the NHMRC report which the NHMRC should have corrected immediately they were aware of what the AMA was doing.

        There is also the issue of these Medical Practitioners personal bias and ideology which has been formed from influences by others which has/could be causing an inability to perform their duties.

        Both the AMA and Practitioners need to read and adhere to their Code of Ethics:

        From the AMA Code of Ethics 2004 revised 2006, the AMA accepts the responsibility for setting the standards of ethical behaviour expected of doctors.

        1.1 Patient Care
        a. Consider first the well-being of your patient.
        b. Treat your patient with compassion and respect.
        j. Refrain from denying treatment to your patient because of a judgement based on discrimination

        a. In order to provide high quality healthcare, you must safeguard clinical independence and professional integrity from increased demands from society, third parties, individual patients and governments.
        b. Protect clinical independence as it is essential when choosing the best treatment for patients and defending their health needs against all who would deny or restrict necessary care.
        c. Refrain from entering into any contract with a colleague or organisation which may conflict with professional integrity, clinical independence or your primary obligation to the patient.

        g. Regardless of society’s attitudes, ensure that you do not countenance, condone or participate in the practice of torture or other forms of cruel, inhuman, or degrading procedures, whatever the offence of which the victim of such procedures is suspected, accused or convicted.

      • I agree.

  2. E Griffiths says:

    A suggestion for STT and all the readers of their blog:

    The “wind turbine noise” you so eloquently write about should be referred to as “WIND TURBINE NOISE POLLUTION” – for that is what it actually is.

    I believe Joe and Joanne Public will perceive the scandal quite differently if all campaigners, including myself, refer to it in future as “WIND TURBINE NOISE POLLUTION”.

    Sleep deprivation and noise are both recognized by the WHO as instruments of TORTURE. The windustry and its band of brown nosed zealous Greentard facilitators and disciples are all complicit in committing MASS TORTURE on countless wind farm neighbours worldwide and/or condoning MASS TORTURE.

    A suggestion to all you readers – ask your local and national Greentard political wind “farm” proponents if they support and condone TORTURE – if the answer is “No” – they should not be supporting the giant fans that are TORTURING so many unwilling wind “farm” neighbours worldwide.

    • Uncle Fester says:

      Or at the very least, it should be rightly called “Industrial Noise”, and be placed under the same scrutiny as any other heavy industry (along with land zoning)

  3. Well, for one thing, AGL is full of bullshit. I know because I have had a bit to do with them. When you front them with questions about noise, infrasound etc, all they say is we are not aware of the issues – there is the first lie and the lies keep going on. That is why they are called Australia’s Greatest Liars.

    It is about time our Federal Parliament put a stop to the wind farms that are the biggest fraudulent scam this nation has ever seen.

    These BLOODY fans will not save this planet in any way shape or form; Prime Minister Tony Abbott, get rid of them.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: