Twitchers given rare treat by turbine

Centuries from now – archaeologists and palaeontologists will be sifting through what were communities of isolated-candle-lit hovels and find the remains of the 21st Century greentards and ecofascists that ended up living in the Stone Age poverty that they were ready to foist upon everybody else.

As they unravel the secrets of what led to the great wind power fraud – that will then be ancient history – the experts will be more than a little perplexed at how these people were able to generate foaming outrage – on the one hand – and benign indifference – on the other – when faced with identical avian outcomes.

Every time an oil rig blows up or an oil tanker runs aground – the greentard is the first to howl “blue murder” and demand an end to the oil industry as soon as birds start washing up on a beach drenched in the black stuff.

Gulf Oil Spill

At least he survived his brush with the energy business.


Photos and footage of the Deepwater Horizon disaster in the Gulf of Mexico and the Exxon Valdez spill filled our papers and TV screens for years afterwards – with well-meaning environmentalists gently washing birds and other critters back to health. No criticism there – nothing wrong with a little human compassion for our feathered friends.

However – the game changes when the greentard is confronted with birds and bats being belted for 6 or sliced to ribbons by giant fans.

Something in the greentards’ wiring fails to connect turbines with the death and destruction they cause.

Is it good old hypocrisy? Is it selective thinking? Is it the fact that their simplistic world view reduces all equations to: “green” – GOOD and fossil fuel – BAD?

Whatever it is – it demonstrates an inability to apply logic to a given situation and the absence of any guiding principle – a point well made by James Lovelock.

If human activity causing death and harm to wildlife is abhorrent and cause for outrage in one circumstance – then – as a matter of principle – it should be abhorrent in all circumstances. Or does greentard thinking – if that’s what it is – reduce to the old chestnut about “the greater good”?

For some birds negotiating 56m blades with their outer tips doing over 350km/h is just case of keeping your head – or NOT. This little encounter with the wind industry was reported by James Delingpole a while back:


Hard to keep your head when all those around you are losing theirs.


Well – maybe STT has missed something. Could there be an upside to these things when it comes to spotting and identifying birds and bats – with real precision?

“Twitchers” are a class of people who are prepared to spend days at a time stuck inside a smelly canvas tent living on cheese and onion sandwiches – armed with nothing more than binoculars and cameras – in the hope of sighting and recording something rare enough to repay their seemingly endless patience.

One of the problems with such fleeting sightings is confirming what it was the flew past the hide. Sometimes the sighting is short – or natural human failings mean that the bird spotters simply can’t be sure.

Thanks to turbine madness – much of that uncertainty has disappeared now for UK’s huge band of devoted twitchers. Rather than trying to spot something flying low and fast at a distance – they can simply walk up to the base of a turbine and collect their rare specimens for much closer inspection.

Back in June – news broke of a possible sighting of the White-Throated Needletail in the Hebrides, off the coast of Scotland.

Twitchers rushed to the island in question in the hope of spotting one of these rare little beauties. But these little fellas rip along at over 160km/h – which makes it hard to spot and harder to confirm as the subject of the sighting.

Here’s video – apparently – showing one on the wing.

Inconclusive proof, surely?

If that was the limit of what the spotters saw – then – no doubt there would have been a long night at the local pub arguing about just what it was that they saw.

However – luck is a fortune – and a nearby turbine came into its own by bringing this speedy little bird back to earth.

dead needletail

Turbines take all the guess work out of bird spotting.


Here’s some more on the “exciting” moment by Will Robinson in the Daily Mail.

Not that video adds much when the subject is an Ex-White-Throated Needletail – here’s some footage of the spotters with their – otherwise – elusive quarry.



How much easier, to simply walk up and pick up your quarry? Here’s Delingpole’s slice on it.

Does away with hours of tedium and all those booze soaked arguments that follow inconclusive sightings – when you can bring your “prize” home in a Glad bag.

Not only do giant fans help eliminate uncertainty when it comes to the rarest of our feathered friends – they’ve also helped get people up close and personal to some of our more familiar airborne giants.

eagle 1


Sure they’re majestic in the air – but with the aid of a paddock full of turbines you get to pick them up and carry them home. Of course if you kill one without the aid of a turbine you’ll face 6 months imprisonment or a $10,000 fine. As the stories in these links show – when lads with a .22 do it – there is media “shock” and “outrage” at a crime worthy of condign punishment.

eagle at waterloo

Kym Dixon up close with one of Waterloo’s Wedge Tails taking a little rest.


But when Kym Dixon collected this – formerly magnificent – victim of Energy Australia’s fans at Waterloo – the response from the media was “whatever” – with the exception of STT Champion, Graham Lloyd.

If you own a turbine you get to “cut” out (so to speak) any risk of time in stir.

Bats cop it too – with the pressure shock waves from the blades crushing their little lungs:



As these things go up around the Globe the numbers of birds and bats killed by turbine blades will only increase and reach hundreds of millions each year. In Spain alone, wind farms are killing between 6,000,000 and 18,000,000 birds every year. The figures come from 136 monitoring studies collected by the Spanish Ornithological Society. Here’s one take on the numbers killed by the Spectator.

A recent study in the US shows that the numbers of bird deaths accredited to turbines underestimates the true figure by more than 30%. (for the full story refer Smallwood, K Shawn. 2013. Comparing bird and bat fatality-rate estimates among North American wind-energy projects. Wildlife Society Bulletin 37: 19-33.)

Back to our poser: is it a kind of religious fervour that causes the greentard to ignore every negative aspect that comes with giant fans and that blinds them to the obvious environmental harm these monsters cause?

STT is struggling – given that wind power is an economic nonsense that can never replace fossil fuel power sources – we can’t see the “greater good” being served by any of this. All we see is a lot of birds and bats being walloped out of existence for no measurable benefit at all.

About stopthesethings

We are a group of citizens concerned about the rapid spread of industrial wind power generation installations across Australia.


  1. Barbara Durkin says:

    The wind industry employs the biologists performing Adaptive Management, monitoring and mitigation for wind projects. Too many have been seduced by the lucre of wind via public subsidies and AM carcass counting contracts. How unfortunate for birds and bats that NGOs and many biologists have sold out the species because they’re beholding to Big Wind rent-seekers and carpetbaggers.

    Thank you for this article.

  2. windaction says:

    Reblogged this on Ontario Wind Resistance.

  3. Reblogged this on gottadobetterthanthis and commented:

    I’ll say it again, I’ll take humans over birds and bats any day. Reference DDT – If one human life can be saved using it, then we should still use it.

    But windmills have limited usefulness. Trying to set up acres of multi-storey-height windmills for support of the electric grid is insane on its own merit. There is no justification for building them in the first place. Given how many birds and bats these things kill, and how brutally, and how they kill our most majestic and most endangered, it is simply immoral.

    • Research Grant says:

      Lonnie, DDT could wipe out the birds and bats without the need for turbines! I understand your sentiment, and the DDT controversy, but there are better alternatives.

      Ironically DDT was seen as a lifesaver in controlling malaria/insects etc in and after WW2 but the profound adverse biological and biosphere effects were discovered after the Nobel had been granted.

      It was a false saviour, just like Wind Generators are…

  4. Jackie Rovensky says:

    It’s amazing just how ‘selective’ the ‘Greentards’ can be.

    I am sure there are still those who have a conscience. With more true greenies out there, who look at this wonderful country/world which has fantastic creatures all around us and marvel at what they see and hear, each and every day – but despair at what is happening in the name of ‘saving the earth’, and asking why would anyone want to live in a world divested of such beauty?

    They know there is a better way, but those who have the power to do good are like the three monkeys – see no evil, speak no evil and hear no evil – where Wind has the unfettered power to determine our future.

  5. The birds play a very importment part in the health of this planet, but the Greentards are allowing the birds to be slaughtered by the useless industrial wind turbines by the thousands. I can not see how wiping out the bird population is looking after the planet. The birds are the scavengers of the earth and get rid of a number of pests for our good.

    If I was to kill a native bird I would fined, but the wind industry know that the wind turbines will kill thousands of birds and it is ok, double standards Greentards, you all should be in jail.

  6. The so called “environmentalist” should listen to these noise files:

    In case it isn’t obvious, these recordings are at 800m from wind turbines and present as highly uncomfortable to the human ear. It is beyond doubt that wind turbines render 1 square km of land into an acoustic wasteland.

    Unlike other forms of energy production, one will have to fill landscapes with thousands and upon thousands of wind turbines and achieve little but ruin many thousands of square kms of land.

    The same false “environmentalist” will show us pictures of animals “happily grazing under turbines”. They don’t compare these pictures to those of chooks “happily” pecking away at corn in crammed battery hen houses, or animals “happily” caged up in zoos.

    In fact the animals that “happily” graze under wind turbines don’t know any better: they don’t go on holidays; they don’t get to choose which paddock they wish to graze in; and much like animals caught up in an oil slick, they don’t discern unprecedented environmental threats like some humans can.

  7. First the Greens complained about cutting down trees, and now they dismiss cutting birds heads off. Greentards,


  1. […] For a discussion on the inherent hypocrisy seen in arguments excusing the slaughter of millions of birds and bats by wind turbines see our post here. […]

  2. […] covered the harm caused to our feathered friends by turbines in posts here and here and […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: