South Australia’s Wind Power Debacle: Destroying an Already Battered Economy

nyrstar port pirie

Nyrstar’s Port Pirie Smelter & 800 jobs about to be blown away…


Insanity is a term that doesn’t even come close to capturing the mania that has gripped South Australia in the last few months. Its hapless Labor government refused to cut a deal to keep Alinta’s Port Augusta power plants up and running and, since their closure in May this year, South Australia has suffered rocketing power prices, routine load shedding and several statewide blackouts (the last on the first day of summer).

In a State with the worst unemployment in the Nation by a whopping margin, its long-suffering citizens are being led into a social and economic disaster unparalleled in Australian history. Some call SA the “canary in the coal mine”, while others talk about the “South Australian wind power experiment”, as if the place was in the outer reaches of the cosmos.

Meanwhile, back on terra firma, business leaders are fed up, frustrated and utterly furious at the manner in which a band of morally bankrupt idiots have destroyed South Australia’s once reliable and affordable power supply. Here’s a couple from The Australian.

Jobs at risk: blackouts spook big companies
The Australian
Michael Owen & Greg Brown
3 December 2016

BHP yesterday stepped up its campaign over crippling energy policies it warned were putting jobs and investment at risk.

Some of the biggest employers and most intensive energy users in the country are so concerned about unreliable power supply in the southern states they are ­reconsidering investment, in a move that would have a devastating impact on tens of thousands of jobs.

The warning comes as the Alcoa aluminium plant in Portland faces increased risk of closure after a major power outage in South Australia and Victoria on Thursday slashed the manufacturing capacity of the plant at the same time it is being crippled with increased energy costs.

Federal Energy Minister Josh Frydenberg told The Weekend Australian that, in the wake of the latest major blackout, state governments must urgently ­address the “disaster” by recognising the importance of getting stable baseload generation to businesses. “Big employers are legitimately wary and concerned about the implications of their investment,” he said. “These are some of the most energy-intensive users in the country.”

The latest energy crisis, at the start of summer, sets up a stoush between Malcolm Turnbull and Labor premiers at next Friday’s Council of Australian Governments meeting in Canberra.

The Prime Minister yesterday slammed “Left ideology that says somehow or other we can pursue these enormous renewable targets”. Mr Turnbull took particular aim at South Australia, saying it was the Weatherill government’s responsibility to “keep the lights on” and warned a “lack of reliability” was a problem in seeking to attract industry.

Jay Weatherill hit back late yesterday, accusing Mr Turnbull of being dishonest and promising a showdown at COAG. “The Prime Minister must stand up to the right wing of his party and reject its pro-coal agenda,” he said.

Federal Industry Minister Greg Hunt yesterday blamed the Victorian Labor government for abandoning energy security with a strong push to renewables, putting industry in that state also at risk.

The Australian Workers Union warned yesterday that the Alcoa plant, which employs 680 workers and indirectly supports 2000 jobs in Victoria’s oldest regional town, may never fully recover as the company took one of the smelter’s two potlines out of action, reducing its manufacturing capacity by 60 per cent.

The Portland smelter, about 350km southwest of Melbourne, lost power for 5½ hours on Thursday because of an issue in the Victorian transmission network, which affected the flow through the Heywood interconnector to South Australia. To balance the South Australian network — powered by gas and a 45 per cent renewables mix plus imported coal-fired generation — 220 megawatts of power was shed from it, blacking out 200,000 homes and shutting down industry.

BHP Billiton’s Olympic Dam mine in South Australia lost power for more than four hours, while other companies including Oz Minerals were affected for six hours. During a September statewide blackout in South Australia, Olympic Dam was without full power from September 28 to October 13. Olympic Dam asset president Jacqui McGill said yesterday the two blackouts in little more than two months had cost it $100 million and “we can’t keep absorbing these kinds of costs”.

BHP yesterday stepped up its public campaign over crippling energy policies it warned were putting jobs and investment at risk. Ms McGill reiterated that BHP building its own power station and disconnecting from the grid was not in South Australia’s best interests, contrary to an assertion by state Treasurer and Energy Minister Tom Koutsantonis that it should do so to avoid further power outages. “We’re at a limit of what we can actually do,” she said. “I can’t secure supply for Olympic Dam right now and that is a deep concern to me and of course the board of BHP Billiton as we look to further invest in Olympic Dam.”

BHP employs 3000 people in South Australia, and a further 43,000 nationally. The company last financial year paid $2.5 billion to the federal and state governments, including $1.3bn in royalties; $62m to South Australia; $753m to Western Australia; $33m to Queensland; and $62m to NSW. The company uses an average of 2880Mw of electricity over a 24-hour period in South Australia, and has a fixed price supply agreement with the operators of the Pelican Point gas-fired power station, Engie.

AWU state secretary Peter Lamps said investors looking at South Australia were worried about power supply and price. “If these two matters can’t be ­addressed companies like BHP, your Arriums and Nyrstars, and others would be reviewing where they do business,” he said.
The Australian

olympic dam

BHP’s Olympic Dam: screaming for reliable & affordable power.


More power to the people
The Australian
3 December 2016

If the electricity outages jeopardising South Australian businesses occurred in a Third World country, many Australians would look on in pity and maybe even think about offering a donation to help. The fact power meltdowns are disrupting lives and economic activity in the world’s most energy-rich nation is testament to the green-Left’s ideological obsession with renewable energy and the breathtaking incompetence of Premier Jay Weatherill’s Labor government.

The haste with which its colleagues in Victoria and Queensland are hurtling down the same ruinous path is equally alarming. The costs of lost production in South Australia and rising power prices in Victoria will be felt nationally.

It is symbolic of the fiasco gripping South Australia that BHP Billiton’s vast Olympic Dam mine, site of the world’s largest uranium deposit, is 265km up the Stuart Highway from Port Augusta, where two coal-fired power stations ceased operations this year, leaving hundreds of workers without jobs. On Thursday, the Olympic Dam operation was without power for more than four hours. The project also was without full power from September 28, during the statewide blackout, to October 13.

On Thursday, power also was cut to other businesses and 200,000 households for hours because of a problem in the Victorian transmission network, on which South Australia relies. The outages left consumers with little confidence about the reliability of supply during heatwaves over the summer, when demand will peak. As Michael Owen reports today, other businesses, from abalone farms to glassblowers, also are being devastated by soaring power prices and equipment damages due to blackouts.

BHP management, understandably, is incensed by South Australian Treasurer and Energy Minister Tom Koutsantonis’s amateurish suggestion that the company should build its own power station for Olympic Dam because it had done so “everywhere else”. In fact, it has done so only in remote locations such as the Pilbara.

The crisis at Olympic Dam will put further expansion of that project in doubt. And, like any user, the mine is entitled to a reliable power supply from the grid, which is the issue at the heart of the crisis. As Malcolm Turnbull said yesterday, if it’s not the responsibility of the South Australian government to keep the lights on in the state, whose responsibility is it? Federal Energy Minister Josh Frydenberg is right to declare South Australia’s “big experiment” with renewables a failure and to point out its overreliance on the Victorian interconnector.

Victoria, too, is beginning to suffer the side effects of its switch to renewables, with energy retailers planning price hikes of more than 10 per cent. Victorian Energy Minister Lily D’Ambrosio’s dubious advice to consumers to “get on the phone and demand a better price from their retailer” is unlikely to help. The closure of the Hazelwood power station could jeopardise the Alcoa aluminium smelter in Victoria’s west and 500 jobs.

Given such considerations, it defies reason that Queensland’s Palaszczuk government, with one of the world’s best coal supplies at the ready, recently adopted a renewable energy target of 50 per cent by 2030. It can only exacerbate Queensland’s financial problems. Bill Shorten has the same target, handing the Prime Minister a gilt-edged opportunity to attack Labor on one of its weak spots. As technology changes, the shift from fossil fuels to renewables will become more cost effective. A premature transition, however, is a blueprint for lost jobs and reduced living standards.
The Australian

Not a bad effort from The Australian’s editor, although we’re pretty sure that South Australians wish that they could ‘transition’ to somewhere other than the Dark Ages. And the line that “the shift from fossil fuels to renewables will become more cost effective” is utter bunkum: the wind industry has been telling the world that it will soon become so cheap as to be viable without subsidies for over a generation – way back in 1984, Christopher Flavin, the President emeritus of the Worldwatch Institute, ran a pitch that in a few years’ time wind energy would not need to be subsidised.

Over 30 years later, and the wind industry the world over still keeps talking itself into circles: one minute it’s ready to take on conventional generators head-to-head; the next it’s wailing about the need to keep the subsidy gravy train running just that little bit longer.

Cut the subsidies and the wind industry will disappear in a heartbeat. However, for South Australians the damage has long been done and there is no escape from the wreckage.

Welcome to your wind powered future!

jay weatherill

Powerless & witless: SA’s lunatic-in-chief, Jay Weatherill.

About stopthesethings

We are a group of citizens concerned about the rapid spread of industrial wind power generation installations across Australia.


  1. New Mexico over $ 1 billion erratic, intermittent, low capacity factor wind turbine projects investment. EDF [Roosevelt wind farm], Siemens [Broadview], Iberdrola [El Cabo]. Our focus and expertise is on wind turbine electronics and software maintenance.

  2. Hi,

    I started a PETITION “SA PREMIER JAY WEATHERILL : Demand the RESIGNATION of the Energy Minister for HIGH POWER PRICES CAUSING SA’s JOBS CRISIS and 15,000 household POWER DISCONNECTIONS, frequent POWER BLACKOUTS and the JULY 2016 POWER CRISIS” and wanted to see if you could help by adding your name.

    Our goal is to reach 100 signatures and we need more support.

    You can read more and sign the petition here:

    Please share this petition with anyone you think may be interested in signing it.

    Thankyou for your time.

  3. Jackie Rovensky says:

    SA was once a power house of activity and had a future for all, it wasn’t that long ago, but the rot began when Dunstan led Labor to victory and went on a spending spree without a thought to where it would lead and they have continued in the mode of promising everything and delivering nothing. That is nothing except a depression which we are now seeing the deepest example of.
    For a while when the Liberals took control and yes sold the Energy company – to pay off the massive State Bank Debt left to them by Labor, unfortunately South Australians demonstrated their short memories and desire to believe in fairy tales and voted Labor back in, and what has been the result – a State that is not facing a depression but is actually in the depths of one.
    It is one which is going to take a lot of guts from a different Government to the useless waste of space of the one we currently have.
    South Australians will also need to have a heart and help a new Government to bring this State back from the bring of insolvency and mass loss of population as people leave through the ‘Open Door’, left open by Labor.
    If Victoria, NSW and Qld think they will avoid the disaster which is SA, they are wrong, unless they stop and take stock and prevent any more closures of base-load energy and prevent more money being wasted on useless ideological dreams which have driven a massive hole into this wonderful Nations future prosperity.
    The Federal Government can help by not continuing to fund useless wind energy companies by shutting off REC’s and CEFC funding. Instead they need to direct funds to those companies which can change and re-fit factories and base-load energy production to reduce emissions.

    • Medias brainwash with the illusions of carbon blankets trapping heat and all that, and that seems to be the base of what needs to change. I think if people understood the basics they would see through the illusions. Have your public official or friend or relative send you a carbon blanket to keep warm or insulate your home, see how they respond. Tell them they can easily make one from by exhaling, put it in a box and even conveniently send it to you by mail. Or you could do the same and send it to them or if you are there standing with them or chatting over dinner simply do it right there, exhale carbon dioxide into your cupped hands and ask them where there is a crack or open window that you can place it there to insulate. People need to understand there are no blankets of carbon in the sky just like there is no insulation in your hands of the carbon dioxide you just put there for them to use as ‘insulation’. 1 miniscule particle of carbon dioxide to 2,499 other particles of air does not insulate anything (400 parts per million).

  4. That mad man Jay Weatherill would have to have manure for brains like all his Labor mates and as for those dirty Green Grubs, they should be taken out to sea and let the great whites deal with them. They all have been told over and over again that all these blackouts would happen and people would be getting their power cut off because of can’t pay because of the extreme price etc, let alone the infrasound and low frequency noise that the corrupt scumbags Companies turbines emit. This renewable energy is all tooth fairy stuff, and is sending Australia bankrupt, Ned Kelly got hung for far less.

  5. Michael Crawford says:

    Commercial “renewable energy” is actually parasite power. It cannot operate unless there is a host baseload and on-demand electricity generation system, since no one (except perhaps South Australians) will accept intermittent electricity supply.

    But because of the insane RECs subsidy system which actually makes it worthwhile for parasite power generators to supply electricity to the grid at even a negative price the parasites destroy the economics of fossil fuel plants which don’t have the subsidy and so the parasite destroys the host upon which it depends.

    All the work of our fine Australian pollies and bureaucrats — whose solid gold pensions are nonetheless secure.

  6. Brian Johnston says:

    What the psychotic left are doing in SA is to my mind criminal.
    This mess is straight out of Stalinism
    Why don’t SA rise up
    Why don’t big business fund a law suit
    Australia is recognised by the OECD as a service economy and it looks like every single big business has to go. I believe that is the reason why the car industry went.
    And Koutsantonis tells BHP to build their own power station.
    Just how are these idiots getting away with this
    Treason is against the Sovereign. Guilty
    Treachery, when it is wilful. Guilty

  7. william gray says:

    BHP is a powerful company and should be seeking to start legal action against the SA govt. Apart from sucking up to this silly Green ideology it’s the only language they understand. When the whole thing collapses as it inevitably will and the electorate is baying for blood,those that instigated this fiasco should be charged with willfull and criminal negligence if only for the tens of thousands that have been unnecessarily disconnected from this essential service. The media generally and esp The Australian though could do a more thorough investigation into the finacial links between big wind and the Greens/labor cohort.

  8. Well well unions finally realised you need jobs to make superannuation before you worry about return on investment. Intermittent to noisy and run on subsidy goodbye turbines we hope.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: