Australia’s Energy Crisis: Subsidised Wind & Solar Obsession Sending Power Prices Into Orbit

Add heavily subsidised and chaotically intermittent wind and solar to your grid and rocketing prices are guaranteed. The Danes know it, the Germans know it and South Australians became the butt of international jokes, because of it.

The relationship couldn’t be clearer: see above the pertinent little graphic from Dr Michael Crawford, which says it all, really.

For, try as they might, Australia’s renewable energy rent seekers are stuck with the fact that despite sunshine and wind being ‘free’, subsidised wind and solar power, anything but.

Some of the more deluded among them have even gone so far as to claim that South Australian power prices have actually fallen thanks to wind and solar. Tackling the truth has never been their strong point – eg: South Australia’s 50% Renewable Energy Fail: World’s Highest Power Prices Caused by Subsidised Wind & Solar

With a warm week coming up across the southern part of the continent, power demand will surge, as will wholesale prices; and there will be the usual round of widespread load shedding and ‘demand management’ (a euphemism paying energy hungry businesses $millions to shut down their operations and stop drawing power from the grid). For South Australians and Victorians it won’t be so much about affording it, but actually having electricity to run their hospitals, their businesses, air-conditioners and the like.

Under the current renewables obsessed policy settings, talk about power prices falling is just so much nonsense. As Alan Moran details below.

Cheaper power coming? Blink and you’ll miss it if our Paris goals remain
Spectator Australia
Alan Moran
11 December 2019

There is a panoply of agencies regulating energy at the Commonwealth level and not all of these seem to be rowing in the same direction. The main agencies are:

  • The Energy and Environment Department with 490 staff in energy and greenhouse — plus another 454 in its dependent agencies:
  • Clean Energy Finance Corporation, the Clean Energy Regulator and the Climate Change Authority;
  • The Australian Energy Regulator (AER) with 283 staff;
  • The Australian Energy Market Commission (AEMC) with 95 staff;
  • The Energy Security Board (ESB) with perhaps 10 staff; and
  • The Australian Energy Market Operator (AEMO) with 670 staff.

Although AEMO is mainly concerned with operational issues, its CEO and a good many of its resources are heavily involved in regulatory matters. Moreover, energy/environment policy is important for other agencies including Agriculture, Industry, Treasury, the ACCC and PM&C. The CSIRO and several other research agencies have considerable resources addressing it, while there are bodies like the Global Carbon Capture Initiative, largely Australian government-funded.

All in all, there are well in excess of 1500 people spread across a dozen federal different agencies involved in energy/greenhouse policy area. With such heavy government engagement, it is to be expected that the sector has been outstanding in terms of its deteriorating efficiency and increased costs. At the very least, the area ripe for the sort of rationalisation that is being undertaken with the government departments.

This week, the AEMC delivered its annual forecasts of household prices and costs covering the next three years. The Government would be welcoming its estimate that prices will rise little in 2019/20 and fall six per cent next year. One cause is suppressed demand induced by wholesale prices that have more than doubled since the subsidised renewables plague caused the 2017 closure of Hazelwood. Also, the sheer size of the subsidy-induced increase in renewable supplies has tended to reduce forward prices; the surge in new supplies has even dented the level of subsidy that these receive.

This replacement of reliable coal by intermittent wind and solar leaves the regulatory agencies on edge each year. This week AEMO, while extolling the benefits of more solar and wind supplies for the coming year, also announced that it had spent $40 million on insurance contracts for supplies and demand reductions that might not have been otherwise available. AEMO is pressing strongly for consumers being forced to fund additional transmission spending to facilitate the increased penetration of wind and solar and more spending on batteries/Snowy 2 to offset their unreliability.

And just in case anyone was thinking that the AEMC’s estimated near–term fall in prices was the harbinger of a turnaround, also this week the Energy and Environment Department published its forecast of greenhouse gas emissions into the future.  This has renewables supplying half of the electricity supply by 2030.  At 40 per cent for wind/solar, this is double their 2020 projected share.

With wind/solar requiring at least $100 per MWh to be profitable (compared with coal at under $50), this means the upward trajectory must resume after the market has digested this year’s temporary glut.

The Department’s forward projections leave Australia at a crunch point because, even though cost-competitive renewables have been heralded for decades, the mirage constantly retreats. Hence, either a new set of regulatory assistance to renewables must be introduced or Australia reneges on its Paris Agreement “commitments”.

The latter approach would not only allow a convalescence and recovery of the battered energy industries but would also provide welcome relief for the agricultural sector. The heavy lifting envisaged to allow Australia to meet its 2030 goals is the prevention of land clearing — which also entails suppression of output. In net terms, this is responsible for all Australia’s emission reductions envisaged between 2005 and 2020.

The dilemma for Australian governments is either to seek prosperity or please “world opinion”, green radicals and doctors’ wives by taking further steps to undermine the economy’s productivity. Those of us concerned about future living standards have to hope that the Trumpian rejection of Paris brings about its abandonment giving scope for the government to revert to the policies that prevailed before climate concerns became the vogue.
Spectator Australia

Try telling a South Australian business their power bills have fallen.

About stopthesethings

We are a group of citizens concerned about the rapid spread of industrial wind power generation installations across Australia.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: