Melissa Ware: a heartfelt “thank you” to Chris Back, Alan Jones & Graham Richardson

Chris Back

Senator Chris Back – gets a note of thanks for standing up.


A few posts back we covered the fantastic Chris Back interview on Sky News with Alan Jones and Graham Richardson – where the Senator from Western Australia gave the wind industry and it’s parasites a terrific serve (see our post here).

One of Pac Hydro’s long-suffering neighbours at Cape Bridgewater – Melissa Ware – has written this heartfelt letter – setting out her appreciation of the work being done by Chris Back and Alan Jones to help bring an end to the greatest economic and environmental fraud of all time – as well as the entirely unnecessary harm caused to decent, hard-working rural people.

To Senator Back and Messrs Jones and Richardson,

Thank you Senator Back, Mr Alan Jones and Mr Richardson on Skynews for this interview informing people about the uselessness of wind facilities. You managed to convey a wide range of issues all Australians face living with wind farms and RET’s, Renewable Energy Targets.

The health effects on neighbours, including hosts, the higher electricity bills we’re all paying, the enormous subsidies paid annually by taxpayers for each turbine; and the fact that turbines are an inefficient and expensive source of power because wind is a limited and unreliable resource that doesn’t always blow. Simply put, when turbines and renewables don’t generate enough electricity to meet needs and demand, prices for energy soar that none of us can afford.

Creating an Australia which is no longer one of the cheapest energy countries, forcing manufacturers and businesses to close due to roll on carbon costs. Every day Australians are impacted yet we haven’t reversed carbon emissions and still rely on back-up coal to meet energy need.

Wind farm noise experienced here at Cape Bridgewater is covered up and Pacific Hydro present as having no idea what we residents are truly suffering from exposure to the many different wind farm sound emissions, the heard noises and unheard infrasound. Community Consultations held with Futureye for residents of Cape Bridgewater, by Pacific Hydro staff, is an attempt by this company to garner trust and be seen to be accountable following its apology to Cape Bridgewater residents in August 2013. An apology for screeching noises Pacific Hydro claimed to have fixed and are still occurring.

Pacific Hydro and the Glenelg Shire Council openly supports the VicWind Alliance, favouring wind energy, also claiming that despite complaints of health impacts near wind turbines, “there is no scientific evidence to show a connection”. See Portland Observer 4.April.2104, p5 ‘Wind Energy Petition launched at Cape Nelson’. There are more than 80 Professionals, such as Professor Salt, whom disagree with that statement. Many are requesting the AMA to apologise and retract their recent position statement claiming a similar view.

I am grateful to Senator Back for doing his research, for standing up to inform the facts, to declare he has been to a wind farm and actually heard them and that when the blades pass the towers there’s a peak noise (amplitude modulation) that wind farms cover up. I blinked away furious tears at the continual injustice we neighbours of wind farms endure from such continued omissions of fact.

Those condoning our suffering ‘wind turbine syndrome’ and wind energy nuisances can’t ignore an Australian Senator. They can’t say it’s in his head, can’t accuse him of ‘nocebo effect’ and can no longer dishonestly claim “turbines are no louder than the fridge”. With this Government committed to independent noise and health studies it’s time to stop fudging the data and making baseless statements when it’s not proven there are no health impacts and it is proven there is nuisance noise in our homes.

Mr. Jones is equally appalled that AGL interfered in health management two years ago, by sending a letter to 12 clinics in the Western District, including 2 in Portland referring wind farm effected patients back to AGL where they are insultingly informed there are no health impacts. It’s an outrage recently revealed in Parliament by Senator Madigan.

My main concern is for residents and workers in homes, aged care, kindergartens and schools in South Portland. Particularly for the students and staff at the Portland Bay Specialist School, about to be impacted by Stage 4 of the Portland Wind Energy Project, which will have bigger towers and turbines than already inflicted on Cape Bridgewater and Cape Nelson.

How is Pacific Hydro going to prevent harm to children with special needs known to be noise sensitive and overstimulated by noise?

William C. Mulvaney, Superintendent of Armstrong Schools in Illinois, has reported wind farm health issues, see–M8

Dr. Chrystella Calvert a Paediatrician in Canada has reported concerns about wind turbines and impacts on his patient Joey, whom has complex developmental issues. See

Like so many mothers wanting to protect their children, Joeys mother Shellie Correia has to fight the Government on his behalf see;

How can Staff and parents protect children in their care when Pacific Hydro allows suffering at Cape Bridgewater to continue for nearly six years without fixing low frequency noise, infrasound and vibration etc. problems which we Cape Bridgewater residents have been reporting since the wind farm started operating.

None of the Capes residents can continue to live and function in our homes as we did prior to the wind development. All effected families have either left semi-permanently or seek regular respite because of wind farm emissions. GP’s and Specialists have advised me to leave my home on the Cape due to impacts on my health. The banks valuer unofficially told me our house and land is unsellable due to the wind farms proximity. How many more people will continue to be ignored or told to move away or take a sleeping tablet? These issues may not be ignored without consequence.

These questions do not have to be answered as part of permit conditions but can Pacific Hydro guarantee no-one in Portland will be sleep deprived nor cause or exacerbate health conditions from their turbines? Have they actively warned people of heart health risks and possible impacts of the magnetic field on pacemakers near wind farms? Have they done proper noise studies pre-construction of Stage 4 where people live and work? Will they conduct proper noise studies showing the peaks and troughs of noise that people hear and the health impacting infrasound after commissioning? Have they already ‘gagged’ those living in close proximity to Stage 4?

Community funding, sustainability and promise of temporary work won’t address growing concerns about a wind industry that brutally divides and sickens previously strongly connected and quiet rural communities all around the world.

Melissa Ware
Cape Bridgewater


Melissa Ware thanks those with courage to stand up for broken communities.

About stopthesethings

We are a group of citizens concerned about the rapid spread of industrial wind power generation installations across Australia.


  1. Jackie Rovenksy says:

    Melissa, your strength of purpose and determination to see this industry removed from doing any further harm is outstanding.
    Not only are you thinking of yourself and your family but you are also thinking and fighting for the right of others who are and will soon be catastrophically damaged by it.

    That children at a school and especially for one for those with special needs is going to be inline of attack is something the Victorian Government should be very concerned about – but are they? It seems not.

    Nor does it seem that enough people living in Portland and district are concerned. I am surprised they are not demonstrating and speaking out at the short-sightedness of a decision to allow these turbines to be installed so close to such an essential service, when there is so much information about the damage and suffering being caused.

    Pacific Hydro should be ‘crucified’ for even thinking of placing their ‘shards of pain and agony’ anywhere near such a place.

    Why anyone would evade the ‘Precautionary Principle’ is mind boggling.

    Doctors should unite behind such people as you Melissa, Senator Back and all those others working to have common sense prevail with the shutting down of this industry – until IT can prove it does no harm, and the promised independent unbiased research has been undertaken and assessed.

  2. Well said Melissa!

    I can only imagine what you & others in similar situations are going through. It continues to leave me stunned, angry & gobsmacked that you are still suffering after so long.

    May the tide be finally turning so that you & others will not have to continue to suffer. In this day & age, it seems insane that this can continue to happen…….I guess that’s why it’s said ‘money is the root of all evil’.

  3. Terry Conn says:

    I am deeply troubled by Melissa’s story and know from my own enquiries and research how ‘true’ her story is. That our fellow countrymen allow this to continue is hard to reconcile with the values I grew up with that I thought were Australian. I , like Melissa apparently, have been totally powerless to right the wrong or even get those in power to listen and respond to anything I have written, regardless of the veracity or truth of it. In this respect we have, therefore, no choice but to hope that people such as senator Back and Alan Jones and Angus Taylor and senators Madigan and Xenophon can carry the day for us. In recognising this we must continue to let those fighting the battle in high places know they have our support and give them the facts so they can be sure they are right to keep battling on our behalf — Melissa, that is why telling your story is so important. Thanks to STT for sharing it.

  4. David Mortimer says:

    Well said Melissa. We do owe a debt of gratitude to Chris Back and the like thinking senators who “get it”.
    I couldn’t help thinking last night as I listened to the news on ABC TV, that during discussion on the IPCC and renewable energy, not once was wind energy mentioned as being part of the energy “mix”.
    Does that mean the message is starting to get through? I like to think so.

  5. There is an old saying, if you can’t get anyone’s attention on a subject, then put a stick in the wheel. That saying means there are a lot of different ways of dealing with problems. I wonder how those corrupt wind weasel goons would deal with it, when the boot is on the other foot. I knew they would cry wolf, for they are cowards and bullies.


  1. […] Mary Morris of South Australia; Dr Andja Mitric Andjic in Victoria; Sonia Trist, Joanne Kermond and Melissa Ware at Cape Bridgewater; Colleen Watts in New South Wales; and, of course, the extraordinary Sarah […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: