Kill the subsidies and the wind industry dies

Alexander Chancellor

Alexander Chancellor: it’s the end of the gravy train that did them in.

In recent weeks the greentard blogs have been overcome with grief as they moan about the almost inevitable consequences of the Coalition’s RET review, the future of the CEFC and now the ARENA fund – yet another taxpayer backed renewable slush fund that faces the chop.

Their wailing and gnashing of teeth undermines their specious little argument that the costs of wind power production has plummeted to such an extent that it’s now economically competitive with conventional generation sources. Were that the case – and, of course, it never will be – then why is the wind industry and its parasites so terrified of the RET review?

Could it be because in the absence of the mandatory Renewable Energy Target – currently 41,000 GW/h by 2020 – backed up by the fine imposed on retailers under the RET legislation (the “shortfall charge” of $65 per MW/h for each MW the retailer falls short of the mandatory target) – there simply is no market for electricity delivered at crazy, random intervals and at four times the cost of conventional power? For detail on how the RET and the shortfall charge work – see our post here.

Australian Chamber of Commerce and Industry’s Chief Economist, Burchell Wilson described the RET as Corporate welfare on a massive scale.

Scrap the RET and Australia will never see another fan erected beyond the handful being slung up now.

The story’s the same the world over – with what is euphemistically called “regulatory uncertainty” bringing the wind industry to a grinding halt.

Here’s The Spectator on the beginning of the end in Britain.

Local protests don’t stop windfarms. Subsidy cuts do.
The Spectator
Alexander Chancellor

8 February 2014

Here in the valley of the River Tove in south Northamptonshire my chickens are laying copiously, my ducks are quacking loudly, and my Jack Russell, Polly, is yapping gaily in celebration of a great victory: the Spanish energy company, which for more than three years has been threatening to desecrate this pleasant bit of countryside with a line of eight giant wind turbines, each taller than Big Ben, has suddenly said it is abandoning the plan after deciding that it is not feasible. The company, Gamesa, belatedly revealed that it would not after all be seeking planning permission for this wind farm in a curt and otherwise uninformative little letter to the Conservative Member of Parliament for South Northamptonshire, Andrea Leadsom, who has gallantly championed the cause of the local community that has been campaigning vigorously against it.

I can’t tell you what a relief this is, not only for the bats whose little lungs will be saved from bursting under the air pressure caused by wind turbines, nor for the horses at Towcester racecourse who will be spared the fear and confusion provoked by the ‘shadow flicker’ of their rotating blades, but also for the many human residents of the valley, including me, whose homes were expected to fall in value by at least 30 per cent if the ‘Tove Renewable Energy Park’, so-called by its planners to suggest bucolic peace and ecological virtue, were to go ahead. We used to feel guilty about putting our own petty interests above those of entire populations fighting global warming; but now that we know that wind farms do nothing whatsoever to reduce carbon emissions (not a single fossil-fuel power station has been closed because of them), we don’t feel guilty any more. We feel, on the contrary, that we have been fighting in a just cause to preserve some of what’s left of the English countryside and of the environs of the listed buildings and monuments in which this otherwise unsung county abounds. There is no conservation body here that hasn’t opposed Gamesa’s plan.

Gamesa hasn’t disclosed its reasons for dropping the project. It would be nice to think that our local action group made a difference; that all those placards attached to trees saying ‘No wind farm here’ had their effect, that the ‘blimp’ (a kind of balloon) flying over Towcester racecourse to show people the extraordinary height of the proposed turbines made a great impression; but I rather doubt it. As Andrea Leadsom says on her website, ‘Gamesa do not elaborate on why they have decided this is not a feasible project but I hope that the recent reductions in government subsidies will have contributed to the decision.’

stop wind turbines

I expect that that was the main reason, because local opposition to wind farms has so far had a poor record of achieving anything. Even when local councils have rejected planning permission for them, their decisions have tended to be overruled by government inspectors on appeal. But the two recent reductions in government subsidies (paid for, incidentally, by hard-up electricity consumers to the further enrichment of already rich landowners) may well have given some energy companies second thoughts. The great Mrs Leadsom is no fan of the European Union, but she warmly supports the European Commission’s proposal to end all subsidies to wind farms on the grounds that the wind industry is now ‘mature’ and should be allowed to operate without taxpayers’ support.

The thing I don’t understand, however, is why energy companies threatening local communities with these frightful impositions are allowed to keep them in suspense for years on end. Here in the Tove Valley we have spent thousands of pounds and held countless unhappy meetings in anticipation of a decision by Gamesa that it has spent years refusing to reveal. Should it not have been obliged to declare its intentions at a somewhat earlier stage? Yes; but we have been luckier than others, such as the people around the village of Helmdon, a few miles north of here, whose hated wind farm proposal has been granted, rejected, and then reopened again, with a final decision now resting in the hands of Eric Pickles, the portly Local Government Secretary.

He is expected to decide in May, and may he decide rightly. For his decision will be an important factor in determining whether Northamptonshire, despite being less windy than any other English county, but because of its lack of ‘national parks, Areas of Outstanding Natural Beauty, green belts or airport exclusion zones, which would get in the way of turbines 125 metres high’ (I quote the CPRE), will remain ‘the wind farm capital of England’ (the CPRE again). It is completely ridiculous that it should be so.
The Spectator

happy chickens

Free to lay in peace at last.

About stopthesethings

We are a group of citizens concerned about the rapid spread of industrial wind power generation installations across Australia.


  1. Jackie Rovenksy says:

    Every delay is a win, every win is a nail in the coffin, and we will triumph.

    WWW doesn’t mean the same as www (world wide web) but stands for WE WILL WIN.

    And our own ‘world wide web’ of concerned groups individuals academics professionals politicians etc. are out there battling to ensure this outcome, the end is nigh for this industry and its lackeys.

  2. I have said for a long time, take the food source away, and the mouse plague will vanish. Take the REC away and the fans will vanish for good, one would hope, then every one can live in peace once again, and get on with our business, making a living.

    Prime Minister Tony Abbott, please hurry these corrupt fan scams to the rubbish tip so they can be buried, once and for all.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: