South Africa: Wind turbines are a rubbish idea

giraffe-and-turbine-540x334

Time to get out of here

Engineers are a breed of their own. Unable to apply anything but logic and masters with facts and figures, the engineer is usually first to identify the nature and scope of any human problem.

Well, P Sker is an engineer who had applied those skills to unravelling the greatest economic and environmental fraud of all time – this time being perpetrated in South Africa.

On wind turbines…
P Sker
News24.com

March 8 2014

Given the parlous state of Eskom and the electricity network, it is natural for citizens to wonder about alternative means of electricity production.

This is also quite topical considering Eskom has awarded something like 1,600MW of renewable power contracts, recently. Mostly wind, but a bit of solar too.

Of course, I have heard some absolute clangers on this subject recently. First prize goes to the muppet who suggested that solar farms (photo-voltaics, or PV) generate during daylight hours, but also be used to charge some large batteries, that can then be used to run through the night.

The other oft talked about technology is wind turbines. Indeed, many people have noticed the massive development of wind farms in recent times, especially in the Eastern Cape.

Allow me to say something unpopular. Wind turbines are the proverbial plaster, when you’ve just had an arm amputated. As an engineer working for a supplier to that industry, I have worked on a number of wind farm projects. And it is my goal today to tell you why these turbines are a rubbish idea.

First, let’s get the subjective stuff out of the way. To me, they are ugly. Other people think they’re just pretty windmills. I would far rather cast my gaze over pristine Eastern Cape countryside, stretching to the sea in the distance, than be faced with 50 lots of whirling blades.

Secondly, they are noisy. This is not something you’d notice from your car on the N2. But the residents of places like Jeffrey’s Bay and Cape St Francis are going to find out soon enough, that a farm of 50 or more turbines, all at full chat, is enough to disturb the sleep.

Third, those spinning blades may seem to be turning quite gently, but because they’re so long (45m from hub to blade tip, typically), even to achieve a very modest rotational speed (revolutions-per-minute), the tips are moving through the air at hundreds of km/h, almost the speed of sound. And at those speeds, the local bird life does not stand a chance. Wind turbines absolutely decimate local populations.

I guess that all of the above could be forgiven, if they were providing a useful quantum of power to our grid. Here’s the thing though… each turbine can provide a maximum of 2.5 to 3MW. A collector of ten units is thus good for (say) 25MW. Compared against an Eskom shortfall of 2,000MW, that is peanuts.

But that’s not all. A typical large windfarm of around 150MW capacity, occupies an enormous tract of land. Very similar in fact, to that occupied by a coal-fired power station. Yet the coal installation can deliver 3,600MW. In other words, wind has an energy density, in terms of the land it occupies, only 1/25th that of coal.

And lastly, when it comes to wind power, ironically, it needs the grid to be there, in order to generate. Yes, wind turbines are unable to supply a small “island” of load, unless the greater grid is present and stable first. This is due to the technology used to manufacture the generators inside the turbine nacelles.

So, the next time someone suggests that wind turbines are the solution to the energy crisis, you can tell them that they’re just plain wrong. Wind turbines only serve to keep the emotional environmentalists happy. The rational, realistic environmentalists are going to suggest something else. Something safe, clean and with an extremely high energy density. Nuclear.

News24.com

Hats off to P Sker. This would all be hilarious if it wasn’t costing power consumers unnecessary billions and giant fans weren’t actually increasing CO2 emissions.

Facts

FACTS – what will get them in the end

About stopthesethings

We are a group of citizens concerned about the rapid spread of industrial wind power generation installations across Australia.

Comments

  1. Jim Hutson says:

    For a little exercise, please dial up Wikipedia, INFRASOUND.
    and relate to what we already know.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: