Europe’s ‘green’ energy transition has turned into high farce, with wind power output collapsing across the continent. The wind Gods are clearly angry. Britain and Germany have been in the doldrums for weeks; the gas needed to plug the gaps is in short supply, with the price of both gas and electricity, skyrocketing. The power market is nothing short of perfect pandemonium.
A while back, Boris Johnson – promoting his push for an all wind powered future – claimed that “it’s easy being green”. Now, at the mercy of the wind Gods, his grid managers are in a constant state of dread and panic, waiting for the moment when the entire UK power grid collapses into a full ‘system black’.
And Boris’ concept of “being green”, apparently includes firing up old coal-fired power plants, as the only reliable generation system, in town.
However, as The Australian’s Economics Editor, Judith Sloan details below, it’s not just Britain that’s suffering the inevitable consequences of the ‘inevitable transition’ to an all wind and sun powered future. The malady appears to have struck every country that has plumped for wind and/or solar as meaningful power generation sources.
Left powerless and in world of renewables pain
4 October 2021
The truth be told, the lead-up to the COP26 climate conference in Glasgow is turning out to be the exact opposite of what British Prime Minister Boris Johnson would have wanted.
His boast of Britain becoming the Saudi Arabia of wind energy is looking like a bad joke as an extended wind drought affected the UK and Europe. This past northern summer, renewable generation in Britain (which is overwhelmingly wind) fell by 16 per cent while generation from fossil fuels rose by 15 per cent.
Just recently, an old coal-fired power plant had to be switched on to ensure there was sufficient supply to meet demand. The few remaining coal-fired plants in Britain are being paid to hang around for this precise eventuality, although the government’s plan (possibly to be revised) is that these plants will be shut down in the next year or two.
Regulated energy bills in Britain have just increased by £139, pushing the average household bill to nearly £1300 (about $2400). About a quarter of electricity bills is made up of environmental and social costs that are designed to fund the government’s decarbonisation energy strategy.
A further substantial increase in household energy bills is expected in six months. Nine energy suppliers in Britain collapsed last month and the industry regulator, the Office of Gas and Electricity Markets, is preparing for the possible collapse of a large supplier.
In the meantime, the energy crisis facing Britain is being mirrored around the world – with the exception of Australia at this stage – with the price of fossil fuel energy skyrocketing. Thermal coal, for instance, is trading at more than $US200 ($275) a tonne, up from a little more than $US50 a tonne this time last year.
Electricity prices are rising rapidly in Spain, where all the coal-fired electricity plants have been closed. Household electricity bills have risen by 35 per cent this year, with the wholesale price of electricity soaring by 250 per cent. The government is attempting to tweak the taxes and charges imposed on electricity bills as well as levy a super-profits tax on suppliers. Electricity prices also are skyrocketing in Italy.
Earlier in the year we saw an energy catastrophe occur in Texas when millions of customers were without power during a particularly cold snap. The state had gone headlong into renewables without creating a capacity market for dispatchable power and without adequate interconnectors with other states (which were short of power in any case). It was only a matter of time before such a calamity would arise.
More recently, California has encountered energy problems, with households facing a series of rolling blackouts. The Californian government had to apply to the federal government to operate a gas-fired power plant at full capacity, contrary to federal climate regulations. There are now plans to build more gas plants. Bizarrely, the one large nuclear plant in California is slated for closure in coming years.
Germany was once the poster child of the transition away from fossil fuels but is facing serious energy problems in relation to supply and price.
Having made the fateful decision to close all its nuclear plants, a process that will be completed in the next few years, Germany is highly reliant on natural gas sourced from Russia. And in the first six months of this year, coal produced more electricity in Germany than wind.
China has been rationing its electricity output with some factories forced to work at less than full capacity and consumers facing potential blackouts. Just last week, a decision was made by the central government to ramp up the stores of coal and liquefied natural gas to ensure the continuity of electricity for the country in the coming cooler months.
Now there is always a possibility that these worldwide problems are short-lived, although the futures markets indicate otherwise. There will be adjustments to demand and supply. But when it comes to supply, there are often long lead times between decisions to invest and the supply coming on. In Britain, for instance, no new gas drilling licences have been granted since 2016.
And while there is a commitment to open a new nuclear installation in Britain – Hinkley Point C – it won’t become operational until 2026. It uses French technology and is funded by Chinese interests. In the meantime, the net contribution from nuclear power in Britain will drop significantly. During the past decade, nuclear power capacity fell by 27,000 megawatts.
More generally across the world, there has been a relative capital strike when it comes to investment in new fossil fuel supplies as investors have decided to mark down any association with fuel sources that are deemed to be inconsistent with action on climate change. It has been easier making money chasing government subsidies for renewable energy and profiting from climate-related financial products.
Even in the US where fracking was the principal reason for that country’s record on reducing emissions – emissions were 14 per cent lower in 2017 compared with 2005 – there has been relatively little recent spending on new gas wells. There are political pressures to impose restrictions on US gas suppliers exporting LNG. Several South American countries are importing gas from the US to offset reduced hydro-sourced electricity.
So as the Glasgow climate conference approaches – and all the hype that goes with it – Johnson may already be regretting his recent assertion made to the UN General Assembly that “it is easy to be green”. It’s clear that it is not easy going green, even though there is generally some low-hanging fruit to pick when the penetration of renewable energy in a grid is relatively small.
While there is a lot of enthusiastic talk about ways to ease the transition – batteries, for instance, which don’t produce power – recent events have underlined the difficulties that can be encountered on the road to net-zero emissions by 2050. Managing the decarbonisation process requires careful planning and allowance for unpredictable events.
When it comes to affordability, reliability and sustainability, many citizens living in democracies may well vote for the government that guarantees the first two features before worrying about the last.
3 thoughts on “‘Green’ Energy’s Epic Fail: Wind Gods Conspire to Ruin Europe’s Wind Power ‘Transition’”
When are these politicians going to do what they are paid for. They are voted in to represent their electorate but they only represent themselves and make decisions that they THINK will get them reelected. I suggest it will come back to bite them on the arse because of the costs and stress they are creating for their electors. Funny how Labor in Australia voted on a green ticket and lost the unlosable election. The Greens and the renewable fanatics dont base their case on facts but lies and mistruths
We should cut off energy supply to 10 Downing Street first before any of us have to experience this “fraud” !!! Let him see how it feels (with Princess Nut Nut) with no heating nor cooking facilities not to mention the ipads, etc. !!!!!
I keep stating the obvious.
Until the apathetic public have to endure the inevitable price rises and blackouts nothing will change. Cheap, reliable “green” energy
is an ideologogical pipedream with our current technology.