Home Wreckers: Finnish Study Finds Wind Turbine Infrasound Unsafe For Residents Living Within 15 Km

The Finns are renowned for their stoicism, but grinding, pulsing wind turbine noise is too much for any sentient being, even the Finnish.

The evidence proving the unnecessary damage done to wind farm neighbours by the noise generated by giant industrial wind turbines is mounting by the day: Germany’s Max Planck Institute has identified sub-audible infrasound as the cause of stress, sleep disruption and more (see our post here); and a Swedish group have shown that it’s the pulsing nature of low-frequency wind turbine noise  (‘amplitude modulation’) that is responsible for sleep problems in those forced to live with it (see our post here).

Making a mockery of planning rules that permit giant industrial wind turbines to be speared within a thousand metres or so of residential dwellings, a Finnish study reckons that the safe setback distance is more like 15,000m.

Pilot study shows no significant reduction in damage caused by infrasound until residents more than 15 kilometers from wind farms 
Finnish Environmental Health – SYTe ry
Suomen ympäristöterveys
10 January 2019

The pilot study carried out in Satakunta and Northern Ostrobothnia in Finland shows that the damage caused by infrasound from wind power plants will only decrease significantly more than 15 kilometers away from wind turbines. The study was carried out by the Finnish Association for Environmental Health (SYTe) in the spring 2016.

– It has been noticed from experience that after the construction of wind power plants, usually within a few months, people in the surrounding area have begun to get a wide range of symptoms, says Markku Mehtätalo, Chairman of the Finnish Association for Environmental Health.

– It is possible to study the matter quite easily and the Finnish authority responsible for the public health, the Department of Health and Welfare (THL), has tried to do this, for example, Mehtätalo continues. However, in THL’s study in 2016, it was assumed that the symptoms would decrease significantly in the first 10 kilometers, with more symptoms near the wind turbines. The study did not take into account the impact of wind farms elsewhere in the environment.

– But it is known from experience that the symptoms of people do not usually decrease at this distance, says Mehtätalo. Measurements have also shown that the infrasound pulses from the wind turbines that are currently being built will not be significantly reduced at this distance. Other risk factors very close to the wind power plants are audible sound and electromagnetic fields.

The research material was collected from Satakunta and Northern Ostrobothnia

The sample of the pilot study meets the requirements of a statistical analysis. The data was collected from Satakunta and Northern Ostrobothnia, mainly from areas where wind turbines were built 0.5– 1.5 years before the interview (see Figure 1 from Northern Ostrobothnia). The subject of the study was about 50 families, with symptoms of each family member found out. A total of about 200 people were involved in the study.

Figure 1. In the yellow-bounded area, the infrasound from wind turbines is almost continuous. The area is located in the south of Oulu Province in Finland.

 

– In addition, the pilot study took into account the location of all wind power plants in Finland and did not exclude beforehand the possibility that the effect of the wind farms could be greater and reach longer than the impact of a single, clearly separated area, says Mehtätalo.

Nocturnal disturbance is a typical symptom caused by infrasound
The basic research question was whether the family had noticed changes in health status in the last six months or a year within. The wording of the question regarding the time was dependent on when the impact of the nearest wind turbines could have started. The interviewees were not told in advance about the possible connection with wind turbines.

– The majority of respondents were unable to name a change in their overall health status. However, they gave many responses to separate symptomatic questions, says Mehtätalo.

– The most typical was sleep disturbance or change in the need for night’s sleep, fatigue and various pains. Only very few, some respondents, considered wind power plants as a possible cause.

Harmful or severe symptoms three times more common near wind turbines
The responses were categorized according to the severity of the symptoms and subjected to a statistical analysis. There were about three times more harmful or more serious symptoms near wind turbines (less or about 15 km from wind power plants) than further away (see Figure 2).

Figure 2. Symptoms of almost continuous or often persistent infrasound exposure (less or about 15 km from wind turbines) and further (over 15 km) from wind power plants.

 

– Based on the analysis, it seems strongly that, after the construction of wind power plants, the majority of people in the surroundings of wind turbines are having concomitant symptoms. Most of the symptoms are typical stress symptoms, says Mehtätalo.

Although some people have suspected that the symptoms are caused by wind turbines, especially if the wind power plants are visible or if they have heard beforehand about their potential harmful health effects, people have symptoms regardless of attitude. – The pilot study shows that the symptoms are not caused by attitudes, says Mehtätalo.

The occurrence of symptoms decreased significantly only over 15–20 km from the wind power plants (see Figure 2). If there are wind turbines in different directions and a person stays a lot in the area, the risk of symptoms increases.

The assumed harmful area caused by infrasound is too small
– Later in 2017, based on infrasound measurements made in different parts of Finland, it has been found out that 15–20 km is a typical distance where the infrasound pulses of wind turbines can be detected by measurements to travel in almost all circumstances, says Mehtätalo [1–4]. According to an American study, infrasound travels under favorable conditions to a distance of 90 km from wind farms [5].

If the sample of the pilot study is representative, about 400,000 of the Finns suffer from symptoms due to wind turbines and only about 10,000 of them combine the symptoms with wind power plants. Because of the small amount of research data, strong conclusions must be taken with caution.

– However, the study clearly shows that in all previous studies, the harmful area has already beforehand been presumed to be too small, says Markku Mehtätalo. – Among other things, the extensive, in-depth material of another American study, used in several publications, has been gathered within a radius of 11.7 km from wind turbines. For this reason, the harmful health effects cannot be found in the studies, because the symptoms do not vary at this distance, he concludes. – syte

Completed translation of the original text: SYTe (2019). “Pilottitutkimus osoittaa infraäänihaitan vähenevän merkittävästi vasta yli 15 kilometrin päässä tuulivoimaloista.” 2016. Available: https://syte.fi/2019/01/10/pilottitutkimus-osoittaa-infraaaanihaitan-vahenevan-merkittavasti-vasta-yli-15-kilometrin-paassa-tuulivoimaloista/

References:
[1] Auniogroup (2017). The Study Starts. Available: https://www.auniogroup.com/en/2017/03/10/tutkimuksen-kaynnistyminen/
[2] Auniogroup (2017). Infrasound from Wind Turbines Is a New Signal in the Environment. Translation. KauppaSuomi 34/2017, s. 6-7. Available: https://www.auniogroup.com/en/2017/09/11/tuulivoimaloiden-infraaani-on-uusi-signaali-ymparistossa/
[3] Auniogroup (2018). Infrasound Measurements of Wind Turbines in the Ilmajoki Region. Available: https://www.auniogroup.com/en/2018/01/15/ilmajoen-alueen-tuulivoimaloiden-infraaanimittaukset/
[4] Auniogroup (2017). Start of the Wind Turbines in Kokkola. Available: https://www.auniogroup.com/en/2017/12/30/kokkolan-tuulivoimaloiden-kaynnistyminen/
[5] Marchillo et al. (2014). On infrasound generated by wind farms and its propagation in low-altitude tropospheric waveguides. Journal of Geophysical Research: Atmosphere. Available: https://agupubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1002/2014JD022821
Finnish Environmental Health

About stopthesethings

We are a group of citizens concerned about the rapid spread of industrial wind power generation installations across Australia.

Comments

  1. The German Department for Enviroment has released a study, where all that effects are listed (half German / Half English explanation) https://www.umweltbundesamt.de/sites/default/files/medien/378/publikationen/texte_40_2014_machbarkeitsstudie_zu_wirkungen_von_infraschall.pdf

    impressive: See picture at page 57

    However, this was before a green left woman became minister (her promovation: “Margarine industry at the Lower Rhine” – no joke)
    Nowadays, we suffer the next green and ignorant women at this position – and the MSM still avoid to tell about that and other studies.

    +++
    Thanks a lot for your efforts

  2. Reblogged this on windfarmaction and commented:
    Knowledge of local impacts regularly show noise at 8km and more due to topography. Knowing that infrasound travels further one cannot be surprised st these findings

  3. Richard Mann says:

    Here is a 28-minute documentary by the science programme “planet e.” of the second German television ZDF — November 4, 2018.
    Many experts are interviewed, including Alec Salt, Washington University Medical School, and the German researchers who did a human fMRI study:

    • This Infrasound for all sources is wrecking peoples lives.
      No one will listen.
      I have no Wind Turbines.
      It is so bad here
      What source I have no idea.
      Sick of my body vibrating when in bed
      My ears are so bad

  4. I have ILFN from INDUSTRY
    NO ONE CARES

    • Mike Jankowski says:

      That’s because you do not understand. I worked 13 years in steel and manufacturing factories and did not miss a shift in 13 years. None of the ILFN in this environment bothered me.

      Meanwhile, after exposure at 4.7 km, after some months of ringing ears, I eventually could not walk.

      Guess what environment allowed me to heal? Moving to a home next to one of the busiest highway with a great lake on the other side. Plenty of noise and ILFN there.

      I suggest you read, rather than type on this issue, as the perpetuation of your simple misunderstanding could further subject people to harm.

      It is not a level issue that can be represented with a dB(A) number, it is one of tonality. A wind turbine produces infrasound at lower frequencies than a jet engine, and with a repetitive characteristic like an alarm clock…

  5. Reblogged this on ajmarciniak.

  6. Believe it completely. Used to live less than 1 km from two turbines and less than 5 km from ten more. As a result, I believe I have developed Menieres disease which has severely restricted my lifestyle, particularly altering my diet (you are forced to become almost salt free) and my right ear has become deaf and is subject to strong tinnitus. Low frequency pulsing is definitely the cause of many metabolic problems although you won’t find many of the bottom feeding scum that promote windpower admitting to it

    • Mike Jankowski says:

      Very sorry this was done to you. I was diagnosed with Menieres at first too, but neither medication nor maneuvers helped. Getting the hell away from my home did.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: