South Australia’s Wind Power Chaos: Victoria’s Coal-Fired Plant its Only Salvation

SA April 2016

Wind cultists have been making the brazen claim that the rampant proliferation of these things in South Australia led to the demise of Alinta’s coal-fired plant at Port Augusta.

The perverse economics of the LRET (and the market distortions of directing RECs – currently worth $80 – to a ‘product’ with NO commercial value) is the culprit, not electricity supplied at crazy random intervals, which, in SA, wind power operators actually pay the grid manager up to $20 per MWh to take, on those occasions when the wind hits its straps for a few hours at a stretch (see our post here). Without subsidies, conventional generators can’t possibly give power away to ‘compete’ on those terms; not if they want to remain solvent, that is.

The wind cult is also pedalling the myth that, with the closure of Port Augusta, CO2 emissions will plummet and, ergo, we will all be saved from imminent global incineration. As with most mantras, it’s more about the faithful’s beliefs, rather than unassailable facts and their inevitable consequences.

As STT has pointed out, just once or twice, if CO2 gas is the existential threat we’re led to believe, then wind power is as sensible as throwing petrol on a raging fire.

In this In Daily piece, Mike Sandiford (Professor of Geology at the University of Melbourne) points out that, from hereon, South Australians will be importing (via interconnectors) the dispatchable supply, once provided from the coal-fired plant at Port Augusta, from another dispatchable supply; namely coal-fired plant located in Victoria’s Latrobe Valley.

Despite the anti-fossil fuel squad’s momentary cheering, the fact is that, from now on, South Australians will largely be powered by Victorian coal: except, of course, on those – increasingly likely – occasions when wind power output totally collapses (on a totally unpredictable basis – see above), the interconnectors hit their thermal limits, overload and fail – leaving them lit by candles (see our post here).

In the result, rather than CO2 emissions falling, they’re just as likely to rise.

Why Port Augusta shutdown won’t reduce carbon emissions
In Daily
Mike Sandiford
12 May 2016


At 9.40 am local time on Monday May 9th the turbines at Alinta’s 520 megawatt Northern Power Station at Port Augusta disconnected from the grid for the last time.

And with it ended more than 50 years of coal-fired power generation in South Australia.

But Northern’s shutdown does not mean that South Australian power supply is coal-free, and it is unlikely to mean that its power consumption is less carbon-intensive, at least in the short term.


[South Australian power dispatch as a percentage of total coloured by fuel type for the period ~ 5:00 am May 9 through to 10 am Monday 10th. Data sourced from AEMO. Units in megawatts. Time is in NEM-time corresponding Australian Eastern Standard time. The vertical dashed line marks the shutting off of the Northern Power station, and the last coal dispatch within South Australia.]

Not long after Northern shutdown, other lights went out across South Australia as storms left a trail of destruction across the network – the weather gods seemingly whipped into a frenzy of excitement.

By early the following morning a new benchmark had been set with wind-power touching 90% of the dispatch onto the South Australian grid.


[South Australian power dispatch as a percentage of total coloured by fuel type for the period ~ 5:00 am May 9 through to 10 am Monday 10th. Data sourced from AEMO.]

The electricity market followed suit, with spot prices rising to $400 per megawatt hour as Northern’s last turbine was shut down, to $480 shortly after, before descending as low as -$34 the following morning.


[5-minute spot prices for the period ~ 5:00 am May 9th through to 10 am May 10th, coloured by NEM region. Units are dollars per megawatt hour. Data sourced from AEMO.]

With power flows across the nation responding to the changing circumstances in South Australia, connected markets followed the merry dance. Across the mainland states, wholesale prices averaged a bit over $90 per megawatt hour across the 29 hour period shown here, about double what we would expect for a typical Autumn weekday. Natural gas did particularly well, returning an average of more than $100 in each of the mainland jurisdictions.


[Volume-weighted wholesale power prices for the period ~ 5:00 am May 9 through to 10 am Monday 10th, by region and by fuel type. Units are dollars per megawatt hour. Data sourced from AEMO.]


[Volume-weighted wholesale power prices for the period ~ 5:00 am May 9 through to 10 am Monday 10th, by region and coloured by fuel type. Units are dollars per megawatt hour. Data sourced from AEMO.]

With the exception of the early hours of Tuesday morning, when the wind generators were firing at 90% capacity and demand was at its lowest, South Australia was importing significant quantities of power from Victoria. Imports topped out at a touch over 600 megawatts in the first few hours after Northern’s shutdown. At the average rate of 194 megawatts across the period, imports accounted for about 15% of South Australian demand.


[Power flows across the two interconnectors linking South Australia to Victoria. Exports are listed as positive values, imports as negative values. The interconnectors MurrayLink (V-S-MNSP1) at nominal 220 megawatt import capacity, and Heywood (V-SA) at nominal 460 megawatts, being upgraded to 650 megawatts. Combined total in black. Units are megawatts. Data sourced from AEMO.]

By way of replacement, and notwithstanding some proposed withdrawals, South Australia has plenty of registered gas-fired power capacity to more than account for the demise of Northern, as evidenced by the fact that gas was dispatching at only around 15% of the registered capacity for the 29 hour period.


[South Australian dispatch coloured by fuel type as percentage of total installed capacity for that fuel. Data from AEMO.]

While there is no apparent short-term risk to supply, South Australian gas generators will be competing with imported Victorian brown coal generators to pick up any deficit left by Northern’s shutdown.

And because the Victorian coal generators are the least expensive on the national market, Northern’s shutdown will, to a large extent, be underwritten by the Latrobe Valley.

As is typically the case, in the hours after Northern’s shutdown Victoria was exporting power both to South Australia and to New South Wales (and if Basslink were not broken, it would no doubt be doing so to Tasmania), at the combined total of about 800 megawatts. That is just a bit less than the typical output of Hazelwood, the country’s most emission intensive power plant at 1.56 tonnes CO2 per megawatt hour sent out power, or Yallourn with an emission intensity of 1.49. In comparison, Northern’s emission intensity is listed at 1.13 by the market operator.


[Power flows across the interconnectors linking Victoria to South Australia (V-S-MNSP1 & V-SA) and to New South Wales (VIC1-NSW1). Note that for time period here, Basslink (V-T-MNSP1) linking Victoria and Tasmania was not operational. Exports are listed as positive values, imports as negative values. Combined total in black. Units are megawatts. Data sourced from AEMO.]

So to the extent that Northern’s output is underwritten by the Latrobe generators, there will unlikely be any net CO2 reductions across the grid due to Northern’s retirement. In fact, there may be an increase.

Whatever, South Australian power supply is definitely not yet coal-free.

More interesting will be how the change in structure of South Australian power supply effects wholesale prices in times of high demand and low winds. If local prices are to be set by more marginal gas, there will be upward pressure on price and volatility. To some extent, that tendency will be offset by the 190 megawatt upgrade in the Heywood interconnect capacity due for completion in the next month or so, which will expand the capacity to import even more of Latrobe Valley’s output in times of need, while allowing for greater export of wind power in times of surplus.

Recent years have seen relatively subdued wholesale power price volatility across the southern states. However, we do not have to look far back in time to see just how sensitive volatility is to changes in supply and demand settings. The years 2007 and 2008 at the height of the Millennium Drought are a case in point. Then South Australian prices averaged almost $63 per megawatt hour and, for the best 5 hours of each day, averaged about $190. By comparison, for 2014 and 2015 the average price was $49, with the best 5 hours of each day yielding just $89.


[Price structure of the national electricity market for the years 2007 and 2008, showing prices by the best daily hourly increments by region. RRP – regional reference price or spot price. Data from AEMO.]

Any possibility of a return to 2007-08 pricing regimes following Northern’s closure would no doubt excite interest in new investment, especially in grid-scale storage. If one believed those prices would be sustained over the long haul, then solar thermal power configured with about five hours molten salt storage, such as being proposed by Solar Reserve, would be an attractive offering. Of course, that would very much depend on how gas prices play out in the future, whether one believes there will be a carbon price, what happens to the RET beyond 2030, and just how much other investment is being considered.

Paradoxically, without new South Australian investment in technologies that help balance wind power’s intrinsic variability, the shutdown of Northern will further cement the Latrobe Valley as the backbone of the Australian electricity system. And that will be grim for the nation’s emissions trajectory.

The fading of the Northern lights illustrates once again the need for an integrated approach to managing the much needed transition to a less emission intensive power supply across the nation.

Mike Sandiford is a Professor of Geology from the University of Melbourne
In Daily


About stopthesethings

We are a group of citizens concerned about the rapid spread of industrial wind power generation installations across Australia.


  1. Just to add to SA’s power security woes recently we have seen the CFMEU threatening to once again hold the Latrobe Valley brown coal power stations to ransom, this time the AGL Loy Yang A 2210MW base load station.
    “The workers are threatening to strike at the Latrobe Valley power plant, which supplies about 30 per cent of Victoria’s power supply.
    AGL Loy Yang general manager Steve Rieniets said the strikes, which would begin as early as next month, could have flow-on effects for the whole industry.
    “Obviously, if that amount of electricity generation is not available, it does have some impact on risk to supply,” Mr Rieniets said.
    “We believe we have bargained in good faith and we will continue to. But we will not accept claims that add unnecessary costs to us and reduce our productivity in a very competitive market.””
    Without being alarmist, just ponder for a moment what loads on the network will be the first to be shed if Victoria faces supply difficulties. You don’t have to be a Rhodes Scholar to work out that power supplies to SA via Heywood interconnection and the Basslink interconnection to Tasmania (due to return to service later this month) will be the first to suffer.
    Burning your bridges as SA has done by closing down its base load power stations is highly irresponsible and likely to cause a lot of pain to the state’s electricity users.

  2. Melissa says:

    Yes and the consequences apart from decimated bird and bat populations and weary, sickened rural folk; sooner or later we face sitting down to bread and butter banquets by candlelight. Probably using imported goods because it will be too expensive to produce them in Australia.

  3. Jackie Rovensky says:

    The past few days the production of wind energy has been at an almost standstill across the grid, with the occasional ‘push’ by one or two of the wind projects managing a bit more than most.
    When checking out the fossil (coal) plants at the same time almost all were operating above capacity and the rest close to it. To feed the whole Grid the Grid will need the Latrobe coal plants to ensure they do not need extensive maintenance shutdowns for sometime to come.
    This situation would not be any different if the Northern power station was still operating, would probably have only lessened the risk of a grid blackout. It was only the closing of Northern that caused the SA Government to bring back on line the Osborn Gas plant, which they had mothballed, and that flooded shortly after when a pump broke down. Just how long can an old resurrected gas plant continue to operate without major problems causing it to shut down, leaving Latrobe to work even harder to keep a supply of electricity flowing through to SA?

  4. analitik says:

    And Sandiford is a full on renewables proponent who often extoles its virtues and capabilities in articles at The Conversation.

    BTW at the start of this month, SA’s wind turbines were less than 20% capacity factor for 4 days straight, under 10% cf for about half of that period with 2 periods where the cf was under 5% for over 12 hours straight.

    I wonder if Mark Diesendorf will mention this at tomorrow’s SA 100% Renewables discussion at the Friend’s of The Earth Meeting in Adealide.

  5. Reblogged this on Climatism and commented:
    “Sooner or later everyone sits down to a banquet of consequences.” – Robert Louis Stevenson

    Spot on.

    This post is a must read to understand the total uselessness of intermittent, expensive and unwanted Industrial Wind power.

    Unlike the feel-good “save the planet” wind industry, the information and statistics in this post deal in fact, not fantasy!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: