What was all THAT about? The Great Wind Rush Hangover

Remember country primary school Christmas concerts when you were 5?

1982 School Concert

Just add sugar – and watch them go wild!


Performer anxiety as you stood up to recite Banjo Paterson’s the Man from Snowy River, off the cuff, to the whole town.  A strangely familiar Father Christmas doling out presents to all the kids in the school.  Gorging on gallons of raspberry cordial, gutsing down lamingtons, fairy cakes and chocolate crackles after the show, as if there was no tomorrow.  Then, suitably refreshed with an almighty sugar hit, running around the Soldiers Memorial Hall like mad things in the dark.  Screaming and yelling like banshees in the night.  Oh what fun!

Remember your first Bachelor and Spinsters Ball?


Remember your first time?


Buffed up in Uncle Ted’s dinner suit – the one that never really fitted; or in some taffeta nightmare that Mum knocked up from material you always suspected was from an old curtain.  Off you went for a night of drunken debauchery in a far-flung wool shed with Mum and Dad’s blessing and words about not bringing the family name into “total disgrace”.


What would their Mothers think?!?


On each of the occasions above, regret inevitably followed irresponsible action.  Yes, the rush of blood, sugar or overproof Bundy felt truly great at the time – but there’s always a tomorrow.


So much for Uncle Ted’s suit?!?


For the seasoned B&S goer the “tomorrow” was always the tomorrow after tomorrow, as they ripped into the “breakfast” keg before sun-up on Sunday morning at the deceptively named “recovery”.

But, eventually, their raging thirsts would peter out, sleep would eventually overcome them and the ultimate “tomorrow” on Monday morning would hit them like a Mack truck.

The youthful examples above simply illustrate one of the laws of physics: that for every grossly irresponsible action there is an equal and opposite, relentlessly punishing reaction.

So it is with the insanity of our rush into wind power over the last decade.

Developed economies in Europe, Canada, the US and Australia all got drunk on the raspberry cordial over the last 10 years.  Beguiled by promises of endless streams of “free” wind power tens of thousands of giant fans went up without any thought for tomorrow.

Well – it’s tomorrow.

The Germans have woken up to the fact that their mighty industrial success is under serious threat from crippling renewables driven electricity costs.  Hundreds of thousands of German homes have been disconnected from the grid because electricity has become a bourgeois luxury.

And worse – the very justification for spending billions of dollars on wind power has turned out to be nothing but a tremendously cruel hoax.  As Ferdinand Fürst zu Hohenlohe-Bartenstein (Chairman of Germany’s Federal Association for Landscape Protection) put it:

Soon we “celebrate” the 20,000th wind plant, without replacing even one single small plant of conventional energy.

Happily – Australia is about to draw a line under the reckless and wanton rush into wind power seen over the last 6 years.

The RET review will get underway shortly and, with it, a complete rethink about energy policy in Australia.

STT hears that the Coalition is all ready to take an axe to the RET – probably the same sharp little number they will use to scrap the Carbon Tax and to wind up the eco-fascist politburo masquerading as the Climate Change Department.  Bye, bye Tim.


Time to buff up that CV, Tim. There must be a job out
there for an expert on extinct giant marsupials, surely?


The rest of the world is waking up with an almighty hangover and will be looking for a packet of Panadol faster than you can say “what the hell was all that about?”

Here’s a Canadian take on the morning after.

Lamphier: Green energy forcing ratepayers into the red
The Edmonton Journal
Gary Lamphier
13 September 2013

EDMONTON – Apparently the path to a cleaner, greener planet isn’t quite as painless as many eco-altruists would have you believe.

From Germany to Spain and Ontario to British Columbia, taxpayers are waking up to the fact that their power bills are going straight up.

A major reason?  Poorly thought out — some would say hopelessly naive — energy policies that encouraged an explosion of highly subsidized solar, wind, biomass and hydro projects, all in the name of saving the planet from evil fossil fuels.

Ironically, in some cases, these policies have led to an increase in carbon emissions.  At the same time, the promised payoff of millions of new green manufacturing jobs has failed to live up to the hype, as Chinese firms undercut their Western rivals.  In Germany, Chancellor Angela Merkel’s single-minded campaign to wean her country off nuclear energy in the wake of Japan’s Fukushima disaster has resulted in increased dependence on coal, the dirtiest of all fossil fuels. German consumers already pay the highest electricity prices in all of Europe.  Now there’s talk in the German press that electricity is becoming a “luxury good” that some simply can’t afford.

The country’s former Green Party environment minister once boasted that the switch to renewables wouldn’t cost taxpayers more than one scoop of ice cream.  Today his successor admits consumers are paying enough to “eat everything on the ice cream menu,” according to Der Spiegel, Germany’s largest news magazine.

“For society as a whole, the costs have reached levels comparable only to the eurozone bailouts.  This year, German consumers will be forced to pay 20 billion euros ($26.6 billion US) for electricity from solar, wind and biogas plants — electricity with a market price of just over 3 billion euros.”

Even those figures may understate the full magnitude of the costs, Der Spiegel says, due to the often perverse, unintended effects of state subsidies.

“If there is too much power coming from the grid, wind turbines have to be shut down. Nevertheless, consumers are still paying for the ‘phantom electricity’ the turbines are theoretically generating,” the magazine notes.  “Occasionally, Germany has to pay fees to dump already subsidized green energy, creating what experts refer to as ‘negative electricity prices.’”

On the flip side, when the wind doesn’t blow, coal power plants are fired up to fill the gap.  That’s why Germany’s carbon emissions actually rose last year while emissions in the U.S. hit a 20-year low, thanks to surging supplies of shale gas, which is slowly displacing coal.

Even more bizarre, many of Germany’s offshore wind turbines aren’t even tied into the electrical grid.  To keep them from rusting, they’re running on diesel fuel.

All of the pain might have been worth it if Germany had won the global race to dominate new green energy technologies.  But that goal looks increasingly dubious, now that China has the lead.

“Chinese firms gouged the German home market with the aid of cheap labour, a cheap yuan, cheap state credit and a global trade system that let them get away with it,” reports London’s Daily Telegraph newspaper.

“The German solar industry has been smashed.  QCells, Conergy, Solon and Solarworld have all gone bust or faced debt restructuring.  The subsidies for feed-in tariffs have been leaked abroad.  Eight of the world’s 10 biggest solar firms are now Chinese.”

Recession-racked Spain, whose massive state subsidies fueled a boom in solar power installations, faces its own woes.  In a bid to wrestle down the deficit, the government has cut subsidies and hiked power bills.

Since total power capacity now exceeds demand by 60 per cent, Spain is trying to stop consumers from generating their own rooftop solar power, by imposing a levy that makes it more costly than simply buying electricity from the grid.

Canada hasn’t been immune to the economic inanities of the so-called green energy revolution, of course.  Just look at Ontario, where former Liberal Premier Dalton McGuinty’s Green Energy Act was supposed to transform the province into a renewable energy powerhouse, helping to offset the loss of a quarter million auto manufacturing jobs over the past decade.

It hasn’t worked out so well.  Like the experience in Germany, Ontario’s fat government subsidies have triggered a boom in additional wind and solar power capacity, enriching private power producers.  But it’s the taxpayers who got stuck with the bill, and it’s going to be a whopper.

“Ontarians have only begun to pay for the the green energy ‘vision’ of Mr. McGuinty and (former Ontario energy minister George) Smitherman,” wrote Globe and Mail columnist Konrad Yakabuski, earlier this summer.

“Electricity rates are forecast to rise by nearly 50 per cent as the government moves toward its target of adding 10,700 Megawatts of renewable power to the grid.  Renewable energy is not the only reason Ontario is set to become the highest-cost major electricity jurisdiction in North America by next year, but it remains one of the biggest. As a result, the province faces further contraction in its manufacturing base unless it subsidizes big electricity consumers.”

And just what are the benefits to Ontario taxpayers?  A cleaner environment?  Lots of new green energy jobs?  First-mover advantage in the race to develop new alternative energy technologies?

“Sadly, none of the above,” wrote Yakabuski.  “With the bulk of Ontario’s baseload electricity capacity coming from emissions-free nuclear power, commissioning massive amounts of wind and solar energy at guaranteed sky-high rates was a dubious idea from the get-go.”
The Edmonton Journal


What the HELL was all that about? For God’s sake – get me some Panadol – NOW!

About stopthesethings

We are a group of citizens concerned about the rapid spread of industrial wind power generation installations across Australia.


  1. Jackie Rovensky says:

    I’m waiting for the next CEC or industry media report that says Australia is the only country where people are complaining, and that our electricity prices are going to be lower if we continue down the road of Wind Energy.
    They are so sure they are on top of the truth not getting out, that they have been successful in keeping it from us.
    Talk about turning a blind eye.

  2. Reblogged this on Mothers Against Wind Turbines and commented:
    Lucky Aussies, on their way to shaking off their turbine troubles!

  3. David Mortimer says:

    Hmmm.. with Ian Mac being given the energy and science portfolios perhaps it is a case of the fox guarding the chickens again? Lets hope not!

  4. Shut them down and then cut them down, and when the dust settles find the ones that sold us out and lock them up.


  1. […] The Germans have just woken up to the fact that wind power is intermittent and insanely expensive.  Some 800,000 German families have had their power supplies cut-off simply because they can no longer afford the crippling cost of power.  But the greatest insult is that – for all that suffering – German wind power has not only failed to reduce CO2 emissions – but – has INCREASED them. […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: