Wind Power: World’s Greatest Joke – UK Left Powerless During the ‘Big Calm’

The greatest joke ever played on the world is the idea that the wind can – and will soon completely – power modern economies.

When the wind disappears for days and even weeks on end, those that promote it tend to get twitchy and change the subject.

Sometimes it’s mutterings about mega-batteries (that don’t exist) or pumping water uphill using electricity from (don’t tell them this part) coal-fired power plants to later deliver hydropower to plug those ever-yawning wind power gaps.

If either giant batteries or pumped hydro were economic, they wouldn’t need buckets of taxpayer’s money. The same is, of course, true of intermittent and unreliable wind power.

As sailors and kite-flyers well-know, planning your progress and/or amusement around the weather leads to mixed results.

Just how intermittent and unreliable the wind can be has been revealed (again) across the UK over the last month or so.

UK Wind Power Becalmed
The Global Warming Policy Forum
John Constable
12 June 2018

Wind power output in the United Kingdom since the end of May has been at low and extremely low levels, confirming, yet again, the observation that wind power contributes little or nothing to security of supply, and so requires a duplication of resources implying a reduction in overall system productivity and so higher costs to consumers.

This is “Onshore Wind Week”, but Aeolus, the fickle god of the winds, has tested his celebrants’ resolve in the run-up to this festival by refusing to blow more than the occasional puff at the United Kingdom’s 9,000 wind turbines (7,000 onshore, 1,800 offshore). In fact, output from the total wind capacity of approximately 16,500 MW has been low to negligible since the 30th of May.

Metered output is available from the Balancing Mechanism Reporting Service (BMRS) for about 11,836 MW or 65% of the wind fleet. The remaining 35% is not visible to the system operator, but on the assumption that it performs as well as the visible capacity we can estimate the total output.

In the whole of May wind power visible in the BMRS generated 2.2 TWh of electrical energy, so the full total would have been approximately 3.4 TWh. The same calculation for the period 1–10th of June suggests a total wind generation of 0.31 TWh, implying a daily average amounting to less than 1/3 of that in the previous month.

In fairness one should note that June has historically often been a low wind month, but this year’s output does seem to be modest even by those historical standards. Indeed, for some hours on some days the fleet output was effectively zero.

On the 3rd of June, for example, between 07.00 and 13.00, during the morning ramp, output from all 16,500 MW of UK wind power fell to some under 100 MW, a load factor of 0.6%. It must be remembered that this was not a matter of choice, but just what the winds had to offer at that moment. The following chart is the half-hourly fuel mix chart for that day, calculated from the Balancing Mechanism data by Dr Moroney at REF:

Figure 1: Half hour metered UK electricity fuel mix data for the 3rd June 2018. Vertical axis: Megwatts; horizontal axis, half-hourly Settlement Period. Source: United Kingdom’s Balancing Mechanism Reporting Service, reprocessed and charted by Renewable Energy Foundation.

 

Gas fired power stations, represented by the dark yellow band, are obviously following load, and have thus filled in for absent wind, a fact that can be confirmed by noting that gas fuelled generation accounted for 45% of electricity in May, a level typical for the whole of the previous year, but have generated 51% of megawatt hours so far in June, a level rarely exceed in preceding months.

It should also be noted that load on the system is low, at just under 30 GW, so there is no question here of the operator struggling to get by. The system managed perfectly well, indeed it seems to run more smoothly and certainly more cheaply without wind.

There have been, for example, no constraint payments to wind power since the 27th of May, when £105,000 was paid to wind farms to stop generating. In fact some £3.8 million was paid in this way over the whole month, with just under £1 million of it paid on the 26th of May alone. For two weeks the consumer has had a welcome holiday from these arguably unjustified costs. What better way to celebrate Onshore Wind Week.

So, this was no crisis, and if anything a rather desirable state of affairs, but nonetheless very instructive. We learn from the last two weeks, and in particular from the pattern of generation on the 3rd of June, that the output even of a very large distributed wind fleet, on- and offshore around the UK, occasionally falls to low levels for days on end, and sometimes to less than 1% of its potential output for several consecutive hours at a time. In effect the entire national wind fleet from North to South, from East to West, was becalmed.

Clearly this could happen at any time, and thus, as experienced engineers have repeatedly indicated, a conservative system operator will prefer to have at hand sufficient conventional, controllable capacity, plus a margin, to meet any probable load on the electricity network. Wind simply cannot be relied upon.

This multiplication of resources must result in the electricity supply system as a whole having a lower productivity than it would otherwise possess, which also implies, and in spite of the fuel saving that wind offers, higher costs to the consumer.
The Global Warming Energy Policy Forum

Now they tell us ….

About stopthesethings

We are a group of citizens concerned about the rapid spread of industrial wind power generation installations across Australia.

Comments

  1. Marshall Rosenthal says:

    The operation was very successful, but the patient died. Governments, you happen to be the energy surgeons. Didn’t you have to take some kind of Hippocratic oath? You know, the one that says that you will do no harm? I guess not.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: