Battlelines Drawn: Victoria’s Wind Power Push Meets Angry & Disciplined Opposition

It’s often forgotten that the diminutive David slew the gigantic Goliath. Discipline, nerve and strategic resolve is what wins battles. And in Western Victoria, there’s no bigger battle than that brewing between wind power outfits and local community defenders.

One of the best of those is retired country lawyer, Tony Edney. He’s the handsome devil seen on the right in the picture above, taken at the wind power fraud rally in Canberra, June 2013.

Ever since then, Tony has been fighting against the wind industry’s lies, bullying and contempt for rural Australians.

Here’s a brilliant piece Tony penned for the Hamilton Spectator.

The Problems with Wind Farms are Real
Hamilton Spectator
Tony Edney
22 February 2018

There is now simply too much information in the public domain for the wind industry and its many, often ill informed supporters, to continue with any integrity their relentless attacks on the credibility of long suffering wind farm neighbours – people who know with certainty they have been adversely affected by the operation of nearby wind turbines, in many cases having to leave their homes permanently as a result.

Problems exist with wind farms, serious problems, long brushed under the carpet, and they exist in every country in the world where ‘Big Wind’ has spread its tentacles, imposing industrial installations on rural communities, initially by subterfuge and stealth, and often leading to their permanent fracturing.

AAT decision
This newspaper has recently reported on the Administrative Appeals Tribunal decision handed down in Adelaide last year, in which a senior Federal Court judge decided that the noise annoyance produced by wind farms was a, ‘plausible pathway to disease.’

The Tribunal importantly considered that the present method of sound measurement was not adequate to detect the level of low frequency sound in a receiver dwelling.

This is high level recognition of what the Waubra Foundation has been saying for eight years.

It should make people think seriously about the spread of wind farms across western Victoria.

Scientists last year, at Germany’s renowned Max Planck Institute, working with functional MRI machines, demonstrated that sub-audible infrasound can be detected by areas of the brain associated with stress or threat responses – the primitive, instinctive brain – also known as the fight or flight, or startle reflex.

And that stimulation over longer periods of time could exert a profound effect on autonomic functions and may eventually lead to the formation of symptoms such as sleep disturbances, panic attacks or depression.

The reports from those living with wind turbine noise emissions mirror precisely what is recorded in the study, the data from which perfectly corroborates their experiences of being woken from deep sleep with their hearts racing, horrible dreams, waking as if startled, notwithstanding that the noise from operating turbines may not necessarily be heard.

A highly qualified group of Swedish researchers are finding similar results and concluding that low frequency amplitude modulation is an important constituent of the annoying quality of wind turbine noise, considered to be far more disturbing than other noise sources at similar sound levels.

Amplitude modulation
Amplitude modulation is the pulsing feature of wind turbine noise brought about by the moving blades passing the stationary tower and it is increasingly being identified as what makes turbine noise so problematic to many people.

Waking in fright in the middle of a deep sleep is an involuntary response.

It is not something these people are imagining as a result of having a negative attitude to wind farms, being gullible or envious of their neighbours – the explanation for wind farm complaints provided by prominent Big Wind supporter, Simon Chapman, who has openly mocked the concerns of distressed residents.

In a paper delivered in December 2017 to the American Acoustical Association in New Orleans, sound expert Steven Cooper outlined how he had been able to reproduce the exact same symptoms experienced by wind farm noise sensitised individuals in their homes, in his Sydney acoustic laboratory, by exposing them to inaudible pulsing, low and mid frequency, sounds recorded in a bedroom at Cape Bridgewater, close to the eponymous wind farm.

A just concluded six-month investigation by Gatehouse Media, a company owning 130 daily, mostly rural, newspapers across the USA found that ‘wind developers representing some of the world’s biggest energy companies divide communities and disrupt the lives of residents’ [and] ‘reporters interviewed more than 70 families living near three dozen current or proposed wind farms and identified through public documents and media reports an additional 400 families living near industrial wind turbines that have publicly complained about shadow flicker, noise and health problems.’

Push back against wind farms
A push back is taking place right around the world against the government sanctioned rolling out of seemingly unrestricted wind farms, with hugely increased in size turbines.

And it is not just a phenomenon in English speaking countries, another ill informed suggestion made by Simon Chapman.

More than half of European executives say resistance to onshore wind turbines in their country is too strong to allow for significant growth, according to a report by business services group Lloyd’s Register, as reported this month.

And that resistance is in part driven by health concerns.

I will conclude with no less an authority than the British Medical Journal that published a scholarly article in 2012 warning about the concerns addressed above.

‘A large body of evidence now exists to suggest that wind turbines disturb sleep and impair health at distances and external noise levels that are permitted in most jurisdictions.’

The problems with wind farms are real.
Hamilton Spectator

About stopthesethings

We are a group of citizens concerned about the rapid spread of industrial wind power generation installations across Australia.


  1. Noel Dean says:

    Over the weekend Trent Crotchin, Richmond’s Captain suffered from migraine headaches after spending time at the Australian Grand Prix so much so he spent time in hospital. How many other people have suffered migraines after visiting the Grand Prix. He spent a few hours with this type of headache, some of us suffered years of trauma because being exposured to excessive noise emissions that can be avoided. Does the sound exposure at the Grand Prix get measured? Does the EPA care enough to do this measurement? During fireworks displays it is well known that many dogs are being subjected to excessive noise exposure. People suffer from similar noise exposure that troubles dogs, after long exposure to wind farm sounds that contain similar high frequency sound that make dogs frightened. This startle effect has long term effects on those affected, even dogs suffer misery because of this exposure.

    Noel Dean

  2. Noel Dean says:

    Why has the wind industry been allowed to cheat for so long ?
    Why has the wind industry not been challenged by the media to provide evidence of the sound investigation reports instead of just saying that they have complied ?
    There is no evidence that the noise at Waubra Wind complies with the noise standard , the reason being it was never measured .it was only a stupid calculation that nobody can explain .
    So when is some one in the media going to request that evidence be made available to the public for all to see that can identify a sound pressure level dBA for any given time from the Minister for planning .

    Noel Dean .

  3. There are so many ill informed commentators ridiculing affected neighbors, they disregard information like this. Heard of a local born and raised policeman’s opinion that the turbines only go swish swish, so that’s the south west region’s police opinion about turbine noise, and one happens to be a Moyne Shire mayor. How you can have two publicy paid jobs at once and do them both justice defies me?

    • Not much swishing going on in my audio recording below Tom, taken near the fully automated Pacific Hydro Cape Bridgewater wind factory.

      More like a moaning siren.

      A Police siren!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: