Base-Load Matters: America Waking Up to its Wind Power Fantasy


For a populous detached from the realities of power generation (or similarly detached from reality, in general) the concept of running on ‘free’ breezes and sunbeams has an almost natural attraction. In much the same way that infants fixate on the colourful, the shiny and the new.

But, most infants tend to eventually grow up: Santa is ultimately rumbled as an all-too-heavy Uncle Jerry; the tooth fairy as a penny-pinching parental dental loss rogue; and the Easter Bunny as parents who – having dragged them to the dentist’s chair for endless rounds of fillings – stand as healthy-living-hypocrites who should have never pumped them full of chocolate in the first place. For some, breaking those childhood bonds is a painful process.

And, so it is, with those struggling with the fact that wind power is, and will always be, utterly meaningless as a power source.

The struggle plays out in this piece from Ryan Yonk (an assistant research professor at Utah State University) and Arthur Wardle (a research associate at Strata, a public policy research center in Logan, Utah).

Ryan and Arthur are still quite clearly struggling with the idea that wind power is nonsense – lines like wind power providing ‘clean renewable energy‘ and being a ‘good supplement‘ show them up for energy generation ‘infants’ with a lot to learn –  but at least they’re prepared to confront some of the facts that make it so.

Why renewables alone cannot meet our energy needs
The Hill
Ryan Yonk and Arthur Wardle
19 August 2016

When Germany met all but 0.3 gigawatts (GWs) of its peak energy demand for a few hours using renewables this May, the excitement generated a lot of headlines. The headlines missed key details, though — during that time, Germany’s fossil fuel plants were still producing 7.7 GWs. The excess had to be sold to neighboring countries on the cheap.

Since then, Germany has been forced to dial back its renewable subsidies and pay billions to maintain coal generators because, despite the ability to generate lots of power from renewables, meeting power demand when renewables weren’t generating quickly became a problem.

Coal, natural gas, nuclear, biomass, geothermal and hydroelectric power are all capable of providing energy 24/7, what energy experts refer to as “base load” energy. Of those, geothermal and hydroelectric are restrained to specific geographical areas, many of which have already been tapped. Biomass is inefficient and only environmentally friendly to a point. Only coal, natural gas, and nuclear provide constant and reliable energy to any significant portion of the United States. Notably missing from this list are solar and wind. As base-load energy sources are phased out in favor of intermittent renewables, grid reliability suffers.

It’s clear that solar and wind provide clean and renewable energy when the sun is shining or the wind is blowing. But when the sun is down or the air is still, they sit, not producing much of anything. In those moments, other sources must fill the gap. Without base-load producers, there simply is not enough energy to sufficiently supply the grid at all times of day, no matter how many solar or wind facilities get tacked on.

Traditional base-load providers (coal and nuclear) take a long time to turn on and off. Natural gas, while capable of being built to ramp up quickly, is often built in slower, combined-cycle systems to reduce costs. For this reason, even at peak production for solar and wind, base-load plants are kept running so they are ready to provide energy when the renewables no longer can.

The delicate balance between base load and intermittent generation can be seen in California, where closure of the Diablo Canyon nuclear facility threatens 9 percent of California’s energy production. While the stated plan is to replace that capacity with “energy efficiency, renewables and energy storage,” that may not be feasible. California is already reliant on huge amounts of solar, enough that they actually had to shut down some solar producers for fear of overloading the grid this March. Practicality indicates that it is more likely that the lost capacity will be made up with natural gas generators.

Despite the need for consistent base-load power, coal plants across the country continue to be shuttered due to the mounting regulatory burden they face. Seventy-two GWs of base load coal generation are set to go offline in coming years. (For context, 72 GWs is enough to power “every home in every state west of the Mississippi River, excluding Texas,” as the Institute for Energy Research notes.) The North American Electric Reliability Corporation (NERC) predicted in 2013 that “insufficient reserves during peak hours could lead to increased risk of entering emergency operating conditions, including the possibility of […] rotating outages.” To make matters worse, even more coal plants have announced shutdowns than NERC assumed when making that prediction.

Keeping a well-functioning grid that provides every American with power on demand requires substantial base-load power capacity. While intermittent renewables like wind and solar can make good supplements, they cannot provide for the energy needs of modern society alone.
The Hill


Everyone ready to grow up, now?

About stopthesethings

We are a group of citizens concerned about the rapid spread of industrial wind power generation installations across Australia.


  1. estherfonc says:


    I started a petition “SA PREMIER JAY WEATHERILL : Demand the resignation of the Energy Minister for HIGH POWER PRICES CAUSING SA’s JOBS CRISIS and also 15,000 household POWER DISCONNECTIONS, frequent POWER BLACKOUTS and the JULY 2016 POWER CRISIS” and wanted to see if you could help by adding your name.

    Our goal is to reach 100 signatures and we need more support.

    You can read more and sign the petition here:

    Please share this petition with anyone you think may be interested in signing it.

    Thankyou for your time.

  2. Reblogged this on Patti Kellar.


    Imposing in there hundreds,
    Such an army on display,
    Those alien grey metal monsters
    I saw while on my way.
    Aliens on our shores have landed,
    So tall, backs straight and true,
    At night they watch through flashing eyes
    Of red, at me and you.

    Some have scaled the mountains,
    Others near schools and homes,
    Of one thing I am certain,
    Those aliens have no souls.
    No “whispering” from their ranks at all,
    An unearthly sound they make,
    It envelops each and everyone,
    No more can humans take.

    Three giant arms revolving,
    Enveloping all around,
    They’re here to ‘save the planet’,
    The biggest “con” I have found.
    Such hideous tall grey monsters,
    Invade green and pleasant lands,
    To stay for generations,
    Unless the people make a stand.

    These aliens feed on power and wind,
    Without either, they will die,
    They’re NOT environmental friendly,
    They’re for profit, (at a cost), that’s WHY.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: